What Does Casey’s Stock’s Winning Streak Really Prove?

CASYYTD+28.1%SPYYTD+9.4%XLPYTD+21.5%
Analyze CASY →

Today’s big story: Could Nvidia Stock Fall 50%? Follow The Cash

Casey’s General Stores (CASY), one of the leading convenience store chains in the United States, sells fuel, groceries and its own pizza. Its stock has beaten the S&P 500 in each of the last five years. A record like that looks like proof of an exceptional company. So how many of 488 large U.S. stocks do you think managed the same five-year run?

Image from Pixabay

How Rare Is Casey’s Winning Streak?

For every one of those five years, Casey’s stock rose more than the S&P 500. The calculation counts each year as twelve months of trading and leaves dividends out.

Period The stock S&P 500
Nov 8, 2021 to Nov 8, 2022 +15.8% -18.6%
Nov 8, 2022 to Nov 9, 2023 +18.0% +13.6%
Nov 9, 2023 to Nov 11, 2024 +49.3% +38.0%
Nov 11, 2024 to Nov 13, 2025 +30.6% +12.3%
Nov 13, 2025 to Nov 16, 2026 +31.5% +10.1%

Price changes over periods of 252 trading sessions each, dividends excluded.

Only 8 of the 488 current S&P 500 members measured did the same. Even one good year is far from certain. In three of those five years, fewer than half of these stocks beat the index at all. Losing to the index is the more common result, and beating it five years running is rare.

Could A Streak Like This Be Luck?

With this many stocks, a few will have long streaks even if no company is better than any other. In a typical year about 43% of these stocks beat the index. Now suppose luck alone decided which ones. Each year you put all 488 names in a hat and pull out about 43% of them as that year’s winners.

Repeat that process five years in a row, and about seven names come out every single time. Seven companies would have a five-year winning streak with no skill involved at all. In fact, 8 companies have such a streak, barely more than luck alone would give. Some may be there on merit and some by luck. You cannot tell from the share price which one Casey’s is.

Did Casey’s Profit Grow Through The Streak?

Casey’s profit, its twelve-month net income with one-time items included, rose in each of the five years of the streak. Profit grew 160.8% over the whole stretch, while the stock rose 250.5%. Rising profit backed the streak in every year. That points to a real cause behind the gains. It does not prove skill.

What To Watch Instead Of The Streak

Profit is still rising. Casey’s net income rose 27% from a year earlier in the first quarter of fiscal 2027, management said on the September 9, 2026 call. Same-store sales of prepared food and dispensed beverages rose 4.8% in that quarter, with whole pies a highlight. Management’s goal is 120 new stores in fiscal 2027.

A streak records only what the share price did, while Casey’s profit shows how the business itself is doing. Casey’s profit growth, due again with its December 2026 report, is the figure to watch. One company’s record can turn on a single quarter. That is why spreading your money across many strong businesses is safer than betting on one streak.

Why Own One Leader When You Can Own 30?

If you like finding quality companies like Casey’s General Stores, the Trefis High Quality (HQ) Portfolio holds 30 of them in equal weight, and has returned more than 105% since its September 2020 launch. You’re welcome to look inside.

See The HQ Portfolio

Spot an error or want more like this? Tell us in 10 seconds.