How Sensitive Is Blackrock’s Stock To Changes In iShares Fees?

BLK: BlackRock logo

Last week, a string of reports claimed that BlackRock (NYSE:BLK) hiked fees for a large number of its iShares Equity Traded Fund (ETF) offerings, based on the asset management firm’s regulatory filing over the weekend. [1] BlackRock’s decision to raise the fees on 40 of the 280 iShares it offers by as much as 3 basis points (0.03%). In some cases the news did not make sense, given the firm’s announcement of slashing fees on six iShares and launching four new low-cost iShares three months ago. [2] As it turns out, BlackRock is actually not raising fees on any of its iShare offerings. [3]

But how would BlackRock’s value be impacted if it actually raised fees? We look at this below and maintain a $213 price estimate for BlackRock’s stock, which is around its current market price.

Relevant Articles
  1. Trailing S&P500 BY 11% YTD, Where Is BlackRock Headed?
  2. Rising 24% In The Last Six Months, How Will BlackRock Stock Trend After 2024 Q1 Results?
  3. Up 10% Since The Beginning Of 2023, What Should You Expect From BlackRock Stock?
  4. Up 10% In The Last Six Months, Does BlackRock Stock Have More Room For Gains?
  5. Will BlackRock Stock Top The Estimates In Q3?
  6. BlackRock Stock Topped The Earnings Consensus In Q2

See our complete analysis of BlackRock’s stock here

iShares Are Easily The Biggest Source Of Revenue For BlackRock

The size of the global Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs) market is currently estimated at $1.8 trillion. [4] And BlackRock is the undisputed leader in the industry boasting a near 40% market share, primarily through its iShares product offerings. BlackRock currently has assets under management worth almost $500 billion in equity iShares and just under $190 billion in fixed income iShares.

At the end of 2011, fees from various iShares offerings added just under $2.2 billion to BlackRock’s top line figures. That is nearly a quarter of its total revenue figure of $9.1 billion for the year. And the contribution from iShares is only expected to have been higher in 2012. The importance of iShares offerings to its business model, and hence the share price, is hence by no means small.

Even A Small Fee Hike Can Raise BlackRock’s Share Price Considerably

BlackRock, the world’s largest asset manager, provides a diversified portfolio of investment offerings to its clients so that they can pick and choose the type of investment, best suiting their risk profiles and target returns. And since it acquired the iShares business from Barclays (NYSE:BCS) in 2009, there has been a lot of demand for iShares.

The chart above shows BlackRock’s fee income from equity iShares as a percentage of the total assets under management, and the figure has been around 0.4% in the past. And while we currently forecast a gradual decline in the fees figure, suppose we assume that BlackRock hikes its fees by 2 basis points on an average for all its ETF offerings. Considering the rates to remain at this elevated level of 0.42% over the forecast horizon, we see that our price estimate for BlackRock’s share increases to $220 from the current value of $213. Making a similar 2 basis point increase in the fixed income iShares fees, pushes this value further to $222.

Hence, a 2 basis point (0.02 percentage points) increase in iShares fees, results in a $9 increase in our estimate for BlackRock’s share price – an almost 5% jump in value.

Then Why Doesn’t BlackRock Go Ahead And Raise Those Fees?

Simple. To make sure that investors do not pull out their money from the iShares because they perceive the fees as too high. The conclusion is quite valid as competitors like Vanguard and Charles Schwab (NYSE:SCHW) have slashed fees on ETFs over recent months. [5] And BlackRock has been quite focused on expanding its presence in the global ETF market, something which it will not be able to achieve effectively if its fees are at significantly higher levels compared to competitors. BlackRock already leverages its brilliant track record to demand a premium compared to competitors, on most of its fund offerings, and the last thing it would want is for investors to move assets to competitors, effectively shrinking the size of the assets it manages represented in the chart below.

Submit a Post at Trefis Powered by Data and Interactive ChartsUnderstand What Drives a Stock at Trefis

  1. No Joke: iShares To Raise Fees On 40 ETFs, IndexUniverse, Dec 31 2012 []
  2. BlackRock slashes some ETF fees, offers cheaper options, Reuters, Oct 15 2012 []
  3. Update: iShares Will Not Raise Fees on 40 ETFs, Benzinga, Dec 31 2012 []
  4. Ambitious iShares chief sees massive ETF growth, Financial Times, Dec 2 2012 []
  5. Vanguard Cuts Expenses on 22 ETFs, NASDAQ, Dec 28 2012 []