Wells Fargo Sues JPMorgan as Banks Start Going After Each Other
Wells Fargo (NYSE:WFC) filed a lawsuit against JPMorgan (NYSE:JPM) yesterday in an attempt to force JPMorgan’s subsidiary EMC Mortgage to buy back a portfolio of 800 defective mortgage loans. [1] The portfolio valued at $558 million was a part of Bear Stearn’s Mortgage Funding Trust 2007-AR2 and is overseen by Wells Fargo as a trustee. Wells Fargo expects JPMorgan, which acquired Bear Stearns in 2008, to assume ownership of the loan portfolio which shows “an alarming rate of defaults and foreclosures.” This is the second instance of a banking institution acting as a trustee suing another bank over a misrepresented a mortgage portfolio given that U.S.Bancorp (NYSE:USB) suing Bank of America (NYSE:BAC) late last month. [2] These lawsuits have set in motion a trend among major banks of going to court against other banks while they themselves face a string of lawsuits concerning legacy mortgage-related dealings.
We currently have a $32 price estimate for Wells Fargo, which is around 30% above the market price. We believe the current low prices reflect the market’s negative sentiments due to uncertainty in the U.S. macro environment and the growing European debt crisis.
[trefis_forecast ticker=”WFC” driver=”3244″]
Wells Fargo is clearly trying to clean-up its books
The size of Wells Fargo’s mortgage business can be understood by the fact that it contributes to more than a quarter of our $32 price estimate. With a portfolio of nearly $350 billion in mortgages, Wells Fargo has had to address concerns among investors regarding the quality of the home loans held by all major banks.
Wells Fargo had already settled a similar issue concerning 2000 mortgage loans with JPMorgan’s EMC business in January this year. The new lawsuit was filed when EMC refused to settle for the next set of 800 mortgages.
These efforts indicate Wells Fargo’s focused efforts on cleaning up its mortgage portfolio to reduce liabilities linked to weak loans, and seems to be an attempt to help build investor confidence in the bank’s asset base.
See our full analysis of Wells Fargo.
Notes:- JPMorgan Unit Must Buy Back $558 Million in Loans, Suit Says, Bloomberg Businessweek, Sept 15 2011 [↩]
- U.S. Bancorp Unit Sues BofA’s Countrywide Over Loan Pool, Bloomberg, Aug 2011 [↩]