Synthesis so far
Updated Nov 19, 2026. What the data says so far; the articles below are the full record, newest first.
What we know, in five lines.
- 2022 was the only year since 2004 when stocks and bonds both fell: the S&P 500 -18.2%, bonds (AGG) -13.0%, a 60/40 mix -15.8%. Built for 2008 or 2022?
- The safe half lost a fifth of its buying power: $1 million in AGG in November 2021 is $986,000 on the statement, about $808,000 after prices. Is 60/40 broken?
- Since 2017, 60/40 took 66 cents of every dollar the S&P 500 lost and gave 65 cents of every dollar it made: less risk, not better risk.
- T-bills did the safe half's job better: 60% S&P 500 and 40% T-bills grew to $1.48M since November 2021, against $1.39M with bonds.
- Bonds pay again: the 10-year yields 5.10% and the 2-year 4.80%, against about 1.0% from S&P 500 dividends. Is 60/40 back?
Why. Bonds protect a portfolio when stocks fall because rates fall too. In 2022 rates rose from near zero, so both halves fell together. The safe half is only safe when it starts with a real yield.
So what. The question isn't 60/40 or not; it's what the safe half is for. Split it between T-bills (they don't fall), bonds (they gain if rates fall) and dividend payers (income that grows), and size it to the worst year you could live through. Dividend payers held up best: 60% SCHD and 40% T-bills bottomed at $924,000 per $1 million, against $801,000 for stocks and bonds. Are dividends the new bonds?
What would change it. Inflation cooling with the 10-year falling: bonds gain and 60/40 works again. The 10-year holding near 5% while inflation cools: lenders want more to hold US debt. Stocks and bonds falling together again.
Open questions. How much gold should a $1 million portfolio own? · Can $2 million pay you $4,000 a month? · Is the bond market wrong about Fed hikes?
About this storyline
For decades, 60% stocks and 40% bonds was the default plan. Then bonds lost money over five years and fell alongside stocks in 2022. Our analyses measure what the mix did, what can replace the safe half, and how much each choice risks in a bad year.
- The bond half: what bonds and T-bills pay now, and what they did in 2008 and 2022.
- The alternatives: dividend funds, gold and cash, with their record in good and bad years.
- Your mix: income from a portfolio, the worst year you could live through, and the split that fits your plan.