Buying SPY At The 2007 Top Still Paid Off

SPYYTD+8.2%SPYYTD+8.2%QQQYTD+7.3%
Analyze SPY →

Today’s big story: Anthropic IPO: Priced For 2031, Or 2036?

The S&P 500 closed down 1.0% on Tuesday, at 7,340.53. SPY, the big fund that tracks the index, is now 6.0% below its Oct 6 closing high. Slides like this make people afraid of buying at a top.

So take a real top. Say you bought SPY at its close of $156.48 on Oct 9, 2007, with $1 million. That was its highest close of 2007. With every dividend reinvested, the $1 million is worth $6,622,369 at Tuesday’s close. That is a gain of 562.2%, or 10.4% a year over 19.11 years.

The cost was time. On price alone, the holding sat below $1 million for 5.43 years. With dividends reinvested, it sat below $1 million for 4.85 years. The usual advice after a fall is to stay invested, often with no numbers on the worst case. This piece puts the worst case in numbers.

How Deep The Fall Went

SPY’s lowest close came on Mar 9, 2009, at $68.11. At that close the $1 million was worth $435,263 on price. That is a fall of 56.5%. On paper, $564,737 was gone. The index itself fell 56.8%, from 1,565.15 to 676.53.

Dividends softened the low a little. With them reinvested, the low was $448,069. That is a fall of 55.2%.

Under Water For Years

On price, SPY first closed back above the 2007 level on Mar 14, 2013, at $156.73. That came more than five years after the purchase. The way back was not clean. SPY closed below $156.48 on 19 more days. The last of them was Apr 22, 2013.

Reinvested dividends got the holder back sooner, on Aug 16, 2012. Even then, the holding slipped under $1 million on 17 more days. The last was Nov 27, 2012. An owner who took the dividends as cash got back to $1 million on Sep 13, 2012. That took 4.93 years.

The holding Price only Dividends reinvested
Value at the Mar 9, 2009 low $435,263 $448,069
Fall from the 2007 top -56.5% -55.2%
First back to $1 million Mar 14, 2013 Aug 16, 2012
Years below $1 million 5.43 4.85
Value on Nov 17, 2026 $4,680,726 $6,622,369

The Dividends Kept Coming

While the price was under water, SPY paid 21 dividends. On the $1 million, they came to $87,046 in cash. The payout did shrink. SPY’s dividend per share fell 20.0% from 2008 to 2009. But every quarterly payment was still made. The shares paid $17,391 in 2008 and $13,919 in 2009.

Today the same shares pay $48,458 a year. That is 4.8% of the original $1 million. This figure is called yield on cost. It is 2.8 times the income of 2008. A new buyer at Tuesday’s price gets a trailing yield of 1.0%. The higher yield is the reward for holding the shares since 2007.

Kept as cash, the 76 payments add up to $571,123. Price plus that cash comes to $5,251,849. These figures count each dividend on its ex-dividend date, a few days before the cash arrives. They are after fund expenses and before any taxes. In a taxable account the tax depends on your situation, so ask a tax adviser. Whether dividends can do the job bonds used to do is the question in Are Dividends The New Bonds?

Selling At The Low Versus Holding On

An owner who sold at the Mar 9, 2009 close left with $457,610. That is the price value plus $22,347 of dividends collected up to then. The holder who stayed has $6,622,369. Both bought at the same top. One sold at the low.

Holding was not free, though. Nearly five years under water is a long time for anyone who needed the money. We think this kind of patience suits money that can wait, not money due in the next few years.

Today’s Slide Next To 2008

The current fall costs this holding real money. Since the Oct 6, 2026 high, the reinvested holding went from $7,044,156 to $6,622,369. That is $421,787 off its peak. Measured the same way, the 2007-09 fall was 9.2 times the current 6.0% slide. If the slide deepens, the 2007 owner still has a large gain to absorb it.

VOO, the other big S&P 500 fund, cannot tell this story. Its daily history in our data starts on Sep 9, 2010, about three years after the top. So only SPY covers the full period since the 2007 top.

This piece belongs to our storyline on the classic stock-and-bond mix and how long-term savers hold up. Our look at whether that mix is still safe covers the bond side.

What to ask next:

The 2007 buyer could not have seen the crash coming, and nobody can time today’s slide either. What carried that money through was not a forecast. It was the choice to keep holding through the surprise.

Stop Guessing. Start Positioning.

No one can predict surprises like this one. The Trefis High Quality (HQ) Portfolio doesn’t try: it holds 30 quality stocks in equal weight, so no single surprise decides your result. Come see how it works.

See How HQ Works

For questions about this article or underlying research, email help@trefis.com.