When SPY Falls 10%, Do Treasury Bonds Still Help?
Bonds have had a bad five years. IEF, a fund of 7- to 10-year Treasury bonds, lost 7.7% in total return over the five years to Tuesday, Nov 17. SPY, the S&P 500 fund, gained 67.3% over the same years. So one camp says the 60/40 mix of stocks and bonds is broken. The other says bonds are back because they now pay more.
This article asks a different question. When stocks fell hard, did bonds soften the blow? The answer is yes, mostly. In 8 of the 10 finished S&P 500 falls of 10% or more since Nov 2002, IEF rose while stocks fell. A 60/40 mix of SPY and IEF lost less than SPY alone in all 10 of them. That includes 2022.
The current fall is the newest entry in our table. SPY is down 6.0% from its Oct 6 closing high. That is short of the 10% line, so it is not a correction yet. Over the same weeks IEF is up 1.8%. The 60/40 mix has lost 48.1% of what SPY lost. That is right at the median of 48.8% in past falls.
This piece is part of our storyline on whether the 60/40 mix still works. Our five-year look at the mix measures the long-run return. This one measures the hedge inside each fall.
How We Counted Each Fall
A fall starts at a closing high for SPY and ends at its lowest close before it gets back to that high. It counts if SPY lost 10% or more in total return, with dividends included. The 60/40 mix is bought at the high and held to the low. Nobody rebalances along the way.
The 2023 dip just misses. SPY fell 10.3% on price but less than 10% with dividends. So it is not in the table. The 1999 and 2000-2002 falls have no bond fund data in our prices, so those rows show stocks only.
Twelve Falls And One Still Open
All figures are total returns in %, from the high to the low.
| Fall | SPY | IEF | 60/40 SPY/IEF |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jul-Oct 1999 | -11.70 | no data | no data |
| Mar 2000-Oct 2002 | -47.50 | no data | no data |
| Nov 2002-Mar 2003 | -14.18 | +6.25 | -6.01 |
| Oct 2007-Mar 2009 | -55.19 | +20.56 | -24.89 |
| Apr-Jul 2010 | -15.70 | +7.18 | -6.55 |
| Apr-Oct 2011 | -18.61 | +13.62 | -5.71 |
| Jul 2015-Feb 2016 | -13.02 | +7.42 | -4.85 |
| Jan-Feb 2018 | -10.10 | -1.16 | -6.52 |
| Sep-Dec 2018 | -19.35 | +3.35 | -10.27 |
| Feb-Mar 2020 | -33.72 | +6.38 | -17.68 |
| Jan-Oct 2022 | -24.50 | -15.38 | -20.85 |
| Feb-Apr 2025 | -18.76 | +2.73 | -10.16 |
| Oct 6-Nov 17, 2026 (open) | -5.99 | +1.79 | -2.88 |
The biggest help came in the biggest fall. From 2007 to 2009, SPY lost 55.2% while IEF gained 20.6%. The 60/40 mix lost 24.9%. That was 30.3 points better than stocks alone.
2022 Was The Exception, Not The Rule
The case against bonds rests mostly on one year. In the 2022 fall, IEF lost 15.4% as stocks fell. The 60/40 mix still lost less than SPY. But it lost 85.1% of what SPY lost. That was the highest share of any fall.
Only one other fall came close to a miss. In early 2018, IEF slipped 1.2%. The mix lost 64.6% of SPY’s drop that time. In the other eight falls, bonds rose.
So 2022 shows what breaks the hedge. Bonds fail when rates jump while stocks fall. Our piece Is Your Retirement Portfolio Built For 2008 Or For 2022? sets those two kinds of falls side by side.
Not Every Bond Fund Hedges The Same
The fund you hold matters. AGG holds the broad bond market, including company bonds. It rose in only 6 of the 9 falls since it started in Sep 2003. In the 2020 crash, AGG lost 1.3%. Over the same weeks IEF gained 6.4% and TLT, a fund of 20-year-plus Treasuries, gained 14.2%.
Longer bonds swing harder both ways. TLT lost 29.3% in the 2022 fall. That was nearly twice IEF’s loss.
Where This Week Sits
On Tuesday, SPY fell 1.0% and QQQ, the Nasdaq-100 fund, fell 0.73%. IEF rose 0.19% and TLT rose 0.21%. That made two days of gains for IEF after two days of losses.
The pain is deeper in tech. QQQ is down 13.5% since Oct 6, the day of SPY’s high. That is more than twice SPY’s fall. A portfolio heavy in QQQ has felt a correction-sized drop already.
The Risk To The Hedge
Bonds gain if rates fall in a sell-off. The risk is the 2022 pattern. If yields jump again while stocks fall, bonds could fall with them.
What a reader can check this week:
- Which bond fund you own. Treasury funds like IEF rose in more falls than the broad market fund AGG.
- How long its bonds are. Longer bonds helped more in 2020 and hurt more in 2022.
- Your mix today. After a fall, the stock share of a 60/40 mix shrinks on its own. These figures assume no rebalancing.
For the yield side, see whether bonds now paying more than stocks brings 60/40 back.
The idea underneath is simple. A hedge is judged inside the fall, not over five calm years. On that test, Treasuries did their job in most falls since 2002.
No one in early October knew this fall was coming, and no one knows where it ends. The record suggests a mix that holds both kinds of assets does not need to know.
Stop Guessing. Start Positioning.
No one can predict surprises like this one. The Trefis High Quality (HQ) Portfolio doesn’t try: it holds 30 quality stocks in equal weight, so no single surprise decides your result. Come see how it works.
For questions about this article or underlying research, email help@trefis.com.