Should You Pick McCormick Stock Over Its Competitors?

MKCYTD-32.4%SPYYTD+8.2%XLPYTD+20.0%
Analyze MKC →

For questions about this article or underlying research, email help@trefis.com.

McCormick (MKC) grew sales faster over its last four quarters than JM Smucker (SJM) or Ingredion (INGR). Yet it trades at a lower price-to-earnings multiple than Ingredion, and it returned the least of the three over the past year. That multiple is low partly because one quarter’s profit ran far above operating income. Take that quarter’s profit out of the four-quarter total, and McCormick would trade at about 25 times its remaining profit, well above Ingredion’s 10.2. Its price-to-sales ratio, at its lowest fiscal quarter-end level in our data back to 2016, suggests investors expect that growth to fade. So how much of that growth is McCormick’s own?

Image from Pixabay

Most Of McCormick’s Growth Came From An Acquisition

Only a small part of McCormick’s growth is its own. McCormick reported on October 1 that constant-currency sales rose 16.5% in fiscal Q3 2026. Just 2 points of that came from organic growth. The rest came from buying McCormick de Mexico. Organic sales rose 1% at Consumer, the segment that sells spices and seasonings in stores. They rose 3% at Flavor Solutions, which supplies food makers and restaurant chains.

On reported revenue, McCormick still grew the fastest of the three. Revenue rose 13.2% over the four quarters to August 2026, while Ingredion’s fell about 1% over its own four quarters to September. Even so, McCormick trades at 8.0 times earnings, compared with 10.2 for Ingredion. In fiscal Q1 2026, McCormick posted consolidated net income of $1,022 million on just $228 million of operating income. Most of that came from an $867 million gain on revaluing its earlier 50% stake in McCormick de Mexico. That one quarter is a large part of why its multiple sits so low. JM Smucker’s multiple does not compare, because the company reported a net loss in its fiscal Q3 2026.

MKC SJM INGR
Four Fiscal Quarters ended 2026-08-31 (Q4 FY2025 to Q3 FY2026) ended 2026-07-31 (Q2 FY2026 to Q1 FY2027) ended 2026-09-30 (Q4 FY2025 to Q3 FY2026)
Market Value (USD million) 12046 14251 5749
P/E 8.0 62.1 (not in the P/E rank) 10.2
Revenue Growth 13.2% 5.1% -1.0%
Operating Margin (before special charges) 16.4% 19.7% 12.0%
Total Return, Incl. Dividends, 2025-11-14 to 2026-11-17 -29.1% 27.1% -12.6%
Data as of 11/17/2026. Revenue growth, operating margin and the net income in the P/E are for each company’s four fiscal quarters in the first row; revenue growth is against the four quarters before. A P/E marked “not in the P/E rank” belongs to a company whose net income was below zero in at least one of those four quarters. Operating margin uses operating income before the special charges line on the income statement. It can differ from GAAP operating income and from the company’s own adjusted operating income.

McCormick’s Operating Profit Before Charges Is Holding Up

Set the fiscal Q1 profit lift aside, and McCormick’s operating income before special charges still rose. It reached $1,263 million over the four quarters to August 2026, up from $1,084 million a year earlier. On a GAAP basis, which counts those charges, operating income fell over the first nine months of fiscal 2026, to $720.9 million from $759.7 million. Both totals include McCormick de Mexico, so not all of the change is McCormick’s own. Before special charges, the company’s 16.4% operating margin over those quarters trails JM Smucker’s 19.7%. It sits well above Ingredion’s 12.0%. But Ingredion is an agricultural products business, not a packaged foods maker, so the two margins are not like for like.

What McCormick’s Low Multiple Leaves Out

The one-quarter profit lift is not the whole discount. McCormick trades at 1.6 times sales, less than half the S&P 500’s multiple. At the end of fiscal Q3 2026, that ratio was the lowest of all 40 fiscal quarter ends in our data, which start at fiscal Q4 2016.

As of its October 1 call, McCormick was preparing to close its planned combination with Unilever Foods. That deal would add more bought growth. Management expects McCormick’s leverage ratio, debt measured against earnings, to start at 4 times when the deal closes. It expects that ratio to fall to 3 times within two years.

McCormick’s own growth shows up in its organic sales. Management guided fiscal 2026 organic growth of 1% to 3%. It expects to land between the low end and the midpoint. It also expects some margin pressure in the fourth quarter as commodity and freight costs rise. If organic growth stays that slow, you would be picking McCormick for growth it bought rather than built.

Before special charges, McCormick’s operating profit is holding up. Its sales growth outside McCormick de Mexico is weaker. Organic sales growth in the fourth quarter, which management will discuss on its January call, is the measure to watch.

McCormick needs more than one report to show it can grow on its own, and you can wait that out more easily by holding a group of quality leaders than a single stock.

Why Own One Leader When You Can Own 30?

If you like finding quality companies like McCormick, the Trefis High Quality (HQ) Portfolio holds 30 of them in equal weight, and has returned more than 105% since its September 2020 launch. You’re welcome to look inside.

See The HQ Portfolio

Spot an error or want more like this? Tell us in 10 seconds.