Should Jack Henry Stock Holders Look At Corpay Instead?

JKHYYTD-1.5%SPYYTD+11.5%XLFYTD+8.4%
Analyze JKHY →

For questions about this article or underlying research, email help@trefis.com.

Jack Henry & Associates (JKHY) and Corpay (CPAY) are both owned for revenue that comes back year after year: Jack Henry’s from banks and credit unions, Corpay’s from businesses’ cross-border and vehicle payments. Corpay’s revenue has grown much faster, at almost the same price on earnings, though it carries far more debt. So does Corpay’s growth come from its own customers, and is its margin holding up?

Image from Pixabay

Corpay’s Own Business Still Grows At Double Digits

Corpay has maintained growth across its existing businesses so far. Management said organic revenue growth reached 11% in fiscal Q3 2026, marking the sixth straight quarter of double-digit organic growth, while reported revenue rose 18%. For 2027, management is again looking for organic growth of 9% to 11%.

Both companies raised their revenue forecasts in early November, though for different stretches of time. Corpay lifted its 2026 revenue guide to $5.35 billion at the midpoint, up from an earlier guide of $5.31 billion, with three quarters of that year already reported. That total includes about $120 million from two businesses Corpay sold in 2026, which will not appear in its 2027 revenue.

Jack Henry announced its raise one quarter into its fiscal 2027. The company lifted its GAAP revenue guide to $2,708 million at the midpoint, up from an earlier guide of $2,697 million. Management also said it expects slower non-GAAP revenue growth in the second half of that fiscal year. Jack Henry is securing more new clients, however, winning nine for its core banking system in fiscal Q1 2027 against four a year earlier.

Jack Henry’s Margin Widened As Corpay’s Narrowed

Corpay still earns the wider operating margin, though its lead over Jack Henry has shrunk. Corpay posted an operating margin of 40.4% over the twelve months ended September 30, 2026. That figure is down from 44.4% two years earlier, and it landed lower in each twelve-month period than the one before.

Jack Henry’s operating margin moved the other way, rising to 25.3% from 22.6% over the same two years and higher each year. Management expects cyber and infrastructure spending, AI work and a data center consolidation project to pressure Jack Henry’s margins in fiscal 2027. Even so, it kept its forecast that the full-year non-GAAP margin will widen by 20 to 40 basis points.

The two companies also fund themselves very differently. Corpay’s total debt equals 37.1% of its market value, against 0.683% for Jack Henry. Corpay management plans to put free cash flow in 2027 toward buybacks or toward buying companies in spend management.

Both Stocks Trade At Similar Earnings Multiples

Jack Henry trades at 24.0 times its last twelve months of earnings, against 24.4 times for Corpay. At that near-equal price, you get two very different businesses.

Corpay is ahead on growth. Its revenue rose 21.2% over the latest twelve months, against 7.5% for Jack Henry. Those are reported figures; Corpay’s organic growth in fiscal Q3 2026 was 11%, against 18% reported growth. Across the last three twelve-month periods, Corpay’s revenue growth averaged 12.4%, against 7.1% for Jack Henry. Corpay also raised five of its revenue and earnings forecasts in its latest release, against three for Jack Henry. Corpay’s were its 2026 revenue, net income, adjusted net income, EPS and adjusted EPS guides; Jack Henry’s were its fiscal 2027 GAAP revenue, non-GAAP revenue and GAAP EPS guides.

Jack Henry is ahead on debt and on the direction of its margin. If Corpay’s growth from its existing businesses slowed, or its margin kept narrowing, a Jack Henry holder who switched would be paying about the same price on earnings for a company with far more debt and less of an edge on growth or margin.

Weighed together, the two split: Corpay leads on growth and margin size, while Jack Henry leads on debt and margin trend. Its growth from existing businesses has held at double digits, while its margin, still far wider than Jack Henry’s, has narrowed for two years. Corpay’s operating margin is the number to watch in its next report, expected in February 2027.

Does This Mean You Should Act On JKHY?

Betting on a single stock is always risky, whichever way you lean. The Trefis High Quality (HQ) Portfolio holds 30 quality companies in equal weight and has returned 105% since its September 2020 launch.

See The HQ Portfolio

Spot an error or want more like this? Tell us in 10 seconds.