JEPI Vs. VOO: The Bigger Payout Ended Far Behind
The JPMorgan Equity Premium Income ETF (JEPI) has a simple pitch. It pays a high income every month, and many buyers expect it to hold up when stocks wobble. Its 12 payouts over the last year came to 8.1% of its price. VOO, the plain S&P 500 fund, paid 1.1%. The yield alone does not show what an investor ended up with. This article counts the dollars on both sides.
We put $1,000,000 into JEPI at its first close on our platform, on Thursday, May 21, 2020. We put the same amount into VOO on the same day. Every payout was taken as cash and not reinvested.
The answer has two halves. JEPI paid $622,307 in cash against VOO’s $152,409. That is $469,898 more income, or 4.1 times as much. But at Tuesday’s close the VOO shares were worth $1,350,360 more than the JEPI shares. Even after counting all its cash, JEPI finished $880,462 behind VOO. The extra income was real. The growth given up was bigger.
Where The Money Ended Up
Over the whole stretch, the JEPI shares gained 13.4% in value, not counting payouts. They ended at $1,134,286. The VOO shares rose 148.5% and ended at $2,484,646. Add the cash each fund paid, and JEPI’s $1,000,000 became $1,756,593. VOO’s became $2,637,055.
Reinvesting the payouts narrows the gap but does not close it. With every distribution put back in, JEPI grew to $1,964,920. VOO grew to $2,729,116.
Tuesday itself was a small test. The S&P 500 fell 1.0%. JEPI fell 0.96% and VOO fell 1.04%. On that day the income fund gave almost no cushion.
The Paycheck Moved Around
Many buyers treat JEPI as a steady paycheck. The yearly dollars tell a different story. The table counts each payout by the date the fund went ex-dividend.
| Year | JEPI income | VOO income |
|---|---|---|
| 2020 (from May 21) | $64,681 | $15,224 |
| 2021 | $83,337 | $20,066 |
| 2022 | $127,411 | $21,948 |
| 2023 | $92,489 | $23,463 |
| 2024 | $84,441 | $24,742 |
| 2025 | $94,524 | $26,086 |
| 2026 (to Nov 17) | $75,425 | $20,880 |
JEPI’s income jumped in 2022 and then dropped back the next year. In 2025 it averaged $7,877 a month. VOO paid far less. But its payout grew in every full year from 2021 to 2025. A retiree who budgeted on JEPI’s 2022 income would have come up short in 2023.
2022 Was JEPI’s Best Case
2022 was the one losing year for both funds, and the only year JEPI beat VOO. In 2022, VOO’s total return was -18.2%. JEPI’s was -3.5%. That same year JEPI paid its largest income of the whole period. It was 5.8 times what VOO paid.
But the cushion came from the cash, not the shares. With the income taken out, the JEPI position still fell 20.0% from its peak to its low. That fall ran from Dec 29, 2021 to Oct 12, 2022. The VOO position fell 25.4% over almost the same months. The JEPI shares fell less, but not by much.
That matters for anyone who spends the payouts. Know the worst case before you need it. For a JEPI holder living on the cash, a 20.0% fall in the shares is the number to plan around.
A Third Choice In The Same Data
The Schwab US Dividend Equity ETF (SCHD) shows the choice is not only JEPI or VOO. On the same $1,000,000, SCHD paid $345,678 in cash. That is less than JEPI paid. Its shares ended at $2,091,412. Counting the cash, SCHD finished $680,497 ahead of JEPI. In 2022 its total return was -3.3%, close to JEPI’s. Its worst price fall, 18.9%, was smaller than JEPI’s.
Over this stretch, SCHD gave up some income for more growth. We have looked before at what a high yield costs in growth. The JEPI dollars here fit that pattern.
Who JEPI Fits
The data shows a plain trade. JEPI turned growth into cash. If you need income now and would spend it anyway, JEPI delivered far more of it. If you are still building wealth, the cost was large. It came to $880,462. If you hold JEPI, one check this week is how much of the payout you spend and how much you put back in.
This piece is part of our storyline on stocks, bonds and income. A recent piece in our wealth series asked how much a portfolio can pay each month. This one shows what the payout cost. Two of today’s pieces ask the next questions:
No fund here paid the most and grew the most. Every choice gave something up, and we built our own approach around that trade. If you have found a better balance, we would genuinely like to hear about it.
Found A Better Strategy? We’d Love To Learn.
Ours is the Trefis High Quality (HQ) Portfolio: 30 quality stocks in equal weight. Since its September 2020 launch it has returned more than 105%, ahead of a benchmark that combines the S&P 500, S&P MidCap and Russell 2000. If yours has done better, tell us about it. If not, come take a look.
For questions about this article or underlying research, email help@trefis.com.