Why Alphabet’s Cheap P/E May Mislead Investors

GOOGLYTD-9.6%SPYYTD+7.9%XLCYTD-9.5%
Analyze GOOGL →

Today’s big story: Could Anthropic Stock Fall 25%?

A reader asked for more pieces like Can Alphabet Stock Rise 30% From Here? Since that piece ran on Nov 10, the stock has slipped 1.7%. It closed at $282.44 on Wednesday. That is 29.8% below the $402.62 close it reached on May 13, its high for the past year.

Alphabet looks like a huge profit machine. Its net income was $235.7 billion in the four quarters to Sep 30, 2026. Most coverage stops at that number. This article asks how much of it came from rising investments, not from the business. Our latest piece on its buybacks left that question open, and this piece answers it.

The answer is a lot. About 44.3% of that net income came from gains on stakes in other companies, after tax. Without those gains, Alphabet’s price-to-earnings ratio rises from 14.7 to 26.5. This ratio, called the P/E, is the share price divided by a year of earnings per share.

How much of Alphabet’s profit came from investment gains?

Alphabet owns stakes in other companies, called equity securities. When their value rises, Alphabet records a gain in its profit, even if it sells nothing. These gains totaled $129.1 billion before tax in the four quarters to Sep 30. In the three months to June alone, the gain was $98.8 billion.

That one gain, counted before tax, equalled 88.1% of the quarter’s net income, which is after tax. Alphabet said other income was $98 billion that quarter, mainly from unrealized gains in its equity securities. It said those gains drove the big rise in net income. Unrealized means the stakes rose in value but were not sold.

Much of Alphabet’s recent profit came from stakes that rose in value on paper. If you want your stocks to put cash in your hands, dividends are one steady way to get it. The Trefis Income Solution pays a dividend yield about 3x the S&P 500’s, and it lost less than the S&P 500 in all 9 big selloffs since 2018. See the metrics.

Does Alphabet’s cash flow match its profit?

Operating cash flow is the cash a business brings in from its normal work. Alphabet’s was $179.6 billion in the four quarters to Sep 30. Net income was 1.3 times that cash. Without the gains, Morningstar’s normalized income was only 0.7 times the cash.

The cash flow statement shows why. In the three months to June, Alphabet took $99.0 billion of investment gains back out of net income there. This cash flow line runs slightly above the $98.8 billion gain on the income statement. That money was profit on paper, not cash in the bank.

The table below shows the last four quarters side by side.

Quarter Net income ($B) Pretax securities gain ($B) Normalized income ($B) Operating cash flow ($B)
Q4 2025 34.45 2.29 32.44 52.40
Q1 2026 62.58 36.95 32.71 45.79
Q2 2026 112.19 98.84 32.23 39.07
Q3 2026 26.47 -9.03 33.85 42.29

Source: Morningstar quarterly financials on the Trefis platform. Normalized income is Morningstar’s net income without unusual items, after its estimate of tax. For Alphabet, the unusual items are the gains and losses on equity securities. Figures are in billions of dollars.

The swing in profit came almost entirely from the gain line. Normalized income stayed between $32.2 billion and $33.9 billion each quarter.

Is this new for Alphabet?

Yes, at this size it is new. A year earlier, pretax securities gains equalled 17.6% of net income. In the latest four quarters they equalled 54.8%. Both figures set pretax gains against net income, so they compare like with like.

In full-year 2023, these stakes even lost $2.1 billion. In full-year 2025, they gained $24.2 billion. The line has grown fast, and it moves both ways.

What P/E is Alphabet really trading at?

On reported earnings, the stock trades at 14.7 times the last four quarters. On normalized earnings, it trades at 26.5 times. The first number looks cheap. The second is a more ordinary price for a large tech company, in our view.

Analysts’ numbers point partly the same way. Their average 2027 earnings estimate is $15.03 a share. That is below their 2026 average of $19.63. We think this gap mostly reflects gains they do not expect to repeat. Still, $15.03 is well above the $10.66 of normalized earnings per share in the last four quarters. On the 2027 estimate, the stock trades at 18.8 times.

Amazon shows the same pattern. Its pretax securities gains equalled 51.7% of its net income in the four quarters to Sep 30. Its P/E is 21.6 on reported earnings and 36.0 without the gains.

What argues against the worry?

The business itself is growing. Operating income, the profit from Alphabet’s own products, rose from $35.9 billion in Q4 2025 to $40.6 billion in Q3 2026. It totaled $157.0 billion in the four quarters to Sep 30. That is more than the $131.2 billion of normalized income, because tax comes out of the second number.

Gains can also turn into losses. In the three months to September, the securities line lost $9.0 billion. Alphabet tied that quarter’s loss mainly to its SpaceX investment. It said net income fell because of it.

Our data cannot split the gains by holding. Alphabet named SpaceX for the September-quarter loss, but it tied the June-quarter gain to its equity securities as a whole. For the stake behind many readers’ questions, see What Does The Anthropic IPO Mean For Alphabet Stock?

What should an Alphabet owner watch next?

  • Watch the securities gain line in the next report, since it can swing either way.
  • Watch normalized earnings per share, which shows the business without the stakes.
  • Watch whether operating cash flow keeps up with net income.

For the cash side, see Is AI Costing Alphabet Holders Their Buybacks?

Our read: Alphabet’s core profit is steady, but its headline profit is not. The low reported P/E rests on paper gains that can reverse, as they did in the three months to September.

Alphabet’s stock is already 29.8% below its May high. Sitting through a fall like that is easier when the rest of what you own drops less.

Could You Hold On Through The Next Fall?

Holding on is easier when your portfolio falls less than the market. For every dollar its benchmark lost, the Trefis High Quality (HQ) Portfolio lost about 81 cents on average, holding 30 quality stocks in equal weight.

See How HQ Held Up

For questions about this article or underlying research, email help@trefis.com.