Is AI Costing Alphabet Holders Their Buybacks?
Today’s big story: Anthropic IPO: Priced For 2031, Or 2036?
Big Tech is spending record sums on AI, and investors worry about the returns. Most of the coverage counts the spending. This article looks at what Alphabet’s owners gave up to pay for it.
The answer sits in the cash flow statement. Alphabet bought back $5.5 billion of its own stock in the twelve months to September 30, 2026. A year earlier, the figure was $55.8 billion. That is a drop of 90.1%. In the first nine months of 2026, Alphabet bought back nothing at all. Its last buyback quarter in the data was the fourth quarter of 2025.
The cash went into data centers. Capital spending is the money a company puts into buildings and equipment. Alphabet’s rose 105.2% in a year, to $159.8 billion over twelve months. Free cash flow is the cash left after that spending. It fell 73.2%, to $19.7 billion. The buybacks of the earlier year were $36.0 billion more than this year’s entire free cash flow.
| Alphabet, twelve months to end of September | 2025 | 2026 |
|---|---|---|
| Capital spending | $77.9 billion | $159.8 billion |
| Free cash flow | $73.6 billion | $19.7 billion |
| Buybacks | $55.8 billion | $5.5 billion |
| Total debt at end of September | $33.7 billion | $141.9 billion |

Alphabet Went Further And Sold New Shares
Alphabet also sold new stock. It raised $42.9 billion from new common shares in the first nine months of 2026. It raised another $19.1 billion from preferred stock, a separate class of shares with its own terms.
It borrowed as well. Net new debt, meaning new borrowing minus repayments, came to $76.3 billion in those nine months. Total debt rose about 4.2 times in a year.
New debt and new shares brought in $138.3 billion in nine months. Capital spending in the same nine months was $132.0 billion. So outside money was larger than the build-out itself.
Owners can see this in the share count. Alphabet’s diluted share count rose 1.4% from the third quarter of 2025 to the third quarter of 2026. In 2020 it averaged 13.7 billion shares. By 2025 it was down to 12.2 billion, after years of large buybacks that peaked at $62.2 billion in 2024.
The Funding Order, In The Company’s Words
Alphabet has not announced a pause in buybacks. The pause shows up only in the cash flow numbers. On the second-quarter call in July, the finance chief was asked about the recent equity and debt raises. She said Alphabet funds its investment first from operating cash flow, then from debt, and most recently from an equity raise. Buybacks are not on that list.
The spending has not slowed. Alphabet first guided 2026 capital spending to $175 billion to $185 billion. By July the range was $195 billion to $205 billion. The October call kept that range and said spending is expected to “increase significantly in 2027”. Alphabet also had $924 billion of future purchase commitments at the end of the third quarter. Free cash flow in that quarter was negative $9.1 billion. The company tied it to capital spending, a build-up of chip inventory and the payment of a European Commission fine.
Microsoft Pays Its Holders, Meta And Amazon Borrow
Big spending does not force every company down this path. Microsoft spent $135.9 billion on capital projects over the same twelve months. It still had $60.0 billion of free cash flow. It paid 80.1% of that to holders in buybacks and dividends. It also repaid more debt than it issued. Last week, we looked at what has changed about owning Microsoft stock.
Meta looks more like Alphabet. It bought back no stock in the fourth quarter of 2025 or in the first nine months of 2026. Its net new debt over twelve months was $51.3 billion. We looked separately at whether Meta’s AI spending is the easiest to cut. Amazon’s free cash flow was negative $46.9 billion over twelve months. Its net new debt over the same twelve months was $124.1 billion. Our look at whether the Anthropic IPO covers Amazon’s cash burn takes that up. Together, the four companies’ twelve-month free cash flow fell 70.3% in a year.
The Strongest Case Against This View
Alphabet closed at $280.20 on Tuesday, Nov 17. That is 14.6 times its twelve-month earnings per share. It is below every year-end multiple from 2020 to 2025. The lowest of those was 19.3 times, in 2022. Alphabet also held $265.1 billion in cash and short-term investments at the end of September.
But the low multiple flatters the stock. Over twelve months, net income was $78.7 billion more than operating income. Part of the profit came from gains outside the core business. In the third quarter, other income was negative $8.2 billion, mainly a paper loss on Alphabet’s SpaceX stake.
The test that would prove this view wrong is simple. If free cash flow climbs back while spending keeps rising, and buybacks restart, the cash squeeze is over. We think that is unlikely soon, given the 2027 outlook and the purchase commitments.
What This Means For Owners
The stock has already paid a price. It closed 30.4% below its May 13 high and 17.7% below its October 16 close. Our look at what decides Alphabet stock now covered that fall.
Falls like this can deepen. After its 2012 peak, Apple first closed 27% below its high in December 2012. From there it fell another 23.4%. Apple then was a different company in a different market. We think the case shows only that a deep fall could go deeper, not that this one will.
Base any decision to sell on the business, not on the chart. The change that matters here is in the cash. If you owned Alphabet for steady buybacks, that part of the story has stopped. If you own it for what the AI spending may earn later, your bet is now bigger and funded partly with debt and new shares. Size the position to the fall you could live with.
Alphabet’s owners have already sat through a drop of about 30% from the May high. The company bought back no stock while it fell. Staying put through the next drop is easier when the rest of your money falls less than the market does.
Could You Hold On Through The Next Fall?
Holding on is easier when your portfolio falls less than the market. For every dollar its benchmark lost, the Trefis High Quality (HQ) Portfolio lost about 81 cents on average, holding 30 quality stocks in equal weight.
For questions about this article or underlying research, email help@trefis.com.