Why GM Looks Far Cheaper Than Tesla On 2030

GMYTD+3.6%SPYYTD+9.4%XLYYTD-0.4%
Analyze GM →

Our Monday look, Tesla Stock At $390.22 Already Prices In Most Of 2030, found that Tesla’s price already pays for a lot of its next four years. The obvious next question: is that just what car stocks cost, or is Tesla an outlier? General Motors is the cleanest test.

The short answer: GM’s 2030 is priced far more cheaply. At Monday’s close GM ($83.67) traded at 3.9 times analysts’ average 2030 adjusted earnings per share. Tesla ($379.74) traded at 44.7 times its own 2030 figure. That is 11.5 times GM’s multiple. Put another way, at GM’s multiple Tesla’s 2030 consensus would price its stock at $32.95; at Tesla’s multiple, GM’s would price it at $964.36.

Even the most hopeful analyst on Tesla does not close that gap. On the highest 2030 estimate Tesla is still at 36.1 times, while GM sits between 3.7 and 4.0 times across its full range of estimates.

electric vehicle charging
Image from Pixabay

Tesla’s price is a bet on what comes after 2030

Analysts already give Tesla far faster growth. Their numbers have Tesla’s adjusted EPS growing about 50.0% a year from 2026 to 2030, against 12.5% a year for GM. Tesla’s 2030 revenue consensus is 162.6% above its 2025 revenue; GM’s is just 5.7% above. Tesla’s chief executive said on the October call that the company is aiming for 5 million vehicles a year by about 2030.

Yet even with all that growth baked in, Tesla still trades at 44.7 times 2030 earnings. Its approximate market value is 44.8 times consensus 2030 net income; GM’s is 3.5 times. In our view, a price like that is not paying for 2030 at all. It is paying for what Tesla might become after it: the Terafab chip plant, which Tesla said will need capital equipment probably north of $100 billion over the long term, and the Optimus robot, which its chief executive expects to start reaching outside customers around the end of 2027.

GM Tesla
Close, Nov 16 $83.67 $379.74
Price / 2026 EPS est. 6.2x 226.2x
Price / 2030 EPS est. 3.9x 44.7x
Yearly EPS growth to 2030, est. 12.5% 50%
Q3 2026 operating margin 7.2% 2.6%

What GM’s “plan” actually is

One caution on the question itself. GM has not published a 2030 target. Its “2030 plan” here means what analysts expect. What GM has said is that 2027 should be better than 2026, if demand holds and cost pressures ease. Its finance chief added that new battery cells and packs should bring another step up in profit in 2028 and 2029. GM also expects supplier EV settlement payments to step down, which it says should help free cash flow next year.

GM has been raising its near-term numbers too. On Oct 20 it lifted 2026 adjusted EPS guidance to $12.75-$13.75 and adjusted automotive free cash flow guidance to $11.5-$12.5 billion. Its board approved a new $20 billion buyback, about 27% of GM’s approximate market value. That matters for EPS: GM’s diluted share count has already fallen 35.2% since 2023. The cost side is the one we flagged in the one number GM holders should watch.

Why cheap can stay cheap

A low multiple is not a free lunch. Four things argue against reading GM’s 3.9 times as a bargain on its face.

  • Thin coverage. GM’s 2030 consensus rests on only 4 analysts, against 9 for Tesla.
  • Adjusted, not reported, earnings. Analysts’ 2025 EPS figure for GM was $10.35, against reported diluted EPS of $3.27. GM’s own 2026 GAAP guidance midpoint is $10.22, well under the adjusted range.
  • Thin cash after spending. In the first nine months of 2026, GM’s company-wide free cash flow was $1.3 billion, while it spent $5.3 billion on buybacks.
  • Debt. GM carried $128.7 billion of total debt at Sep 30, much of it from its lending arm, against $27.8 billion of cash and short-term investments. Tesla held $45.2 billion of cash and investments against $16.4 billion of debt.

Markets have also long paid low multiples for carmakers whose profits swing with the economy. Tesla’s premium, in our view, reflects that investors do not see it as only a carmaker. That is the bet: if the robot and chip businesses grow into large earners after 2030, the current multiple can look reasonable later. If they don’t, the stock carries a lot of hope for a company with a 2.6% operating margin last quarter.

What a reader can do with this

Both stocks fell on Monday with the market: GM 2.7%, Tesla 2.7%, the S&P 500 1.9%. Over a year the paths split. GM is up 18.6%, Tesla down 6.1%, while the S&P 500 ETF rose 10.1%.

If you own GM, the test to watch is whether the better 2027 GM described shows up, and whether cash after spending grows enough to fund the buyback without leaning on the balance sheet. If you own Tesla, the question is not the 2030 delivery count. It is whether there is real evidence, such as outside Optimus deliveries in 2027, that the after-2030 story is starting. For more on that, see what could surprise Tesla investors on the upside.

The idea underneath is simple. Price tells you what the market already expects, so the cheaper stock is not automatically the better buy. One stock is priced for little change; the other for a new business that does not exist at scale yet.

Each of these is a single, concentrated bet on how one company’s next decade plays out, and either one can surprise. That is why spreading money across several strong companies, rather than picking the one winner, tends to be the steadier path.

Why Own One Leader When You Can Own 30?

If you like finding quality companies like General Motors, the Trefis High Quality (HQ) Portfolio holds 30 of them in equal weight, and has returned more than 105% since its September 2020 launch. You’re welcome to look inside.

See The HQ Portfolio

For questions about this article or underlying research, email help@trefis.com.