What Would A Short Seller Say About Boeing?

BAYTD-23.9%SPYYTD+9.4%XLIYTD+7.6%
Analyze BA →

Today’s big story: Could Nvidia Stock Fall 50%? Follow The Cash

If you own Boeing (BA), the last three months have been painful: the stock lost 25.9%, while the S&P 500 slipped 3.3%. A short seller betting the stock keeps falling would start with the outside pressure management discussed on its October 27 call: high fuel prices at the airlines.

Management sounded calm about it, saying fuel is pushing airlines that replace older planes “to really want these aircraft sooner.” It is a comforting story. It speaks to demand for new planes, but how well does Boeing’s own business hold up?

Image from Pixabay

Boeing’s Peers And Its Own Past Point Elsewhere

Not very well, a short seller would say. Measured over each company’s own latest four quarters, Boeing grew revenue 17.5%, faster than four of five aerospace and defense peers. Yet its operating margin was minus 0.174%, while those peers kept between 10.4% and 18.2% of revenue as operating profit. GE Aerospace grew faster, at 19.6%, and still earned an 18.2% operating margin.

This weakness is not new. Boeing posted an operating loss in every twelve-month period ended September since 2021, with the deepest at minus 11.9% of revenue in the period ended September 2022. A short seller would argue that a loss that old is not about today’s fuel bill.

Boeing’s Management Named A Production Problem

Management was candid that much of the strain sits inside Boeing. On the October 27 call, management said the 737 was taking longer than expected to run steadily at rate 47, or 47 planes a month, and that getting fully stable would run into 2027. Because of that delay, management expects 737 deliveries in 2026 to fall short of the 500 delivery target.

Management was just as plain that getting wing output stable has been a challenge. On November 9, Boeing announced it would cut 5% of its commercial airplane workforce because the production increase is slower than expected. That is a factory problem, not a fuel problem, and management deserves credit for saying so.

Where Boeing’s Strain Shows Up In Cash

Over the twelve months to September, Boeing turned $94.9 billion of revenue into just $7 million of free cash flow. It pays no dividend and buys back no stock.

The reported profit over those months looks healthier than the business behind it. Net profit for the twelve months was $7.66 billion, while operations lost $165 million. In fiscal Q4 2025, Boeing booked an $8.22 billion profit on an operating loss of $815 million, so something outside the business lifted the twelve-month result.

What Boeing Has Going For It

Boeing’s twelve-month operating margin is the best of the six periods since 2021, up from minus 10.4% a year earlier, and the company earned a small operating profit in each of the last three quarters. Debt has fallen to $45.9 billion, from $62.4 billion five years earlier.

Management points to a record backlog of $745 billion and expects about $3 billion of free cash flow in 2027, rising to about $10 billion in 2029. On fuel itself, management said that so far the airlines have mostly passed the higher cost into ticket prices. At the end of September, the stock traded at 1.6 times sales, lower than at most quarter-ends of the past ten years.

On these figures, fuel explains little of Boeing’s weakness, which shows up in operating losses that go back years and in production lines where management itself has admitted delays. Boeing’s operating margin is the number to watch when the company next reports, expected in January 2027.

Management’s own cash targets run out to 2029. That is a long time to keep a large share of your savings tied to one company, and a good reason to know in advance what would make you change course.

Too Much Riding On One Stock?

If Boeing is a big part of your wealth, so are its risk and its tax bill. What’s your exit plan? Our partner advisory firm offers a free 30-minute strategy review covering a floor under losses and a lower-tax way out.

Map My Exit Options

Spot an error or want more like this? Tell us in 10 seconds.