Should Anthropic Thank Ilya Sutskever?

SPYYTD+5.8%QQQYTD+5.4%
Analyze ANT →

Today’s big story: Will 2027 Be A 2022 Repeat For Stocks?

Anthropic listed on Nasdaq on Thursday. Its offer price was $83 a share, about $1.1 trillion for the company. It closed its first day at $97.17, about $1.3 trillion.

Anthropic began in 2021, when a group of OpenAI researchers left to start it. Two years later, OpenAI was in chaos. On Friday, Nov 17, 2023, OpenAI’s board, including its co-founder and chief scientist Ilya Sutskever, removed CEO Sam Altman. Within days Altman was back. Sutskever left in 2024 and co-founded Safe Superintelligence.

So did OpenAI’s crisis send businesses looking for a second AI supplier? And did Anthropic catch them? A more useful question for your money: what is a leader’s exit worth? We answer both.

Image from Pixabay

Did The Crisis Hurt Microsoft?

For one day.

Microsoft had invested $13 billion in OpenAI. Its stock is the one market price on the crisis. It fell 1.7% on Friday, Nov 17, while the Nasdaq 100 fund was flat. That was a dent of roughly $47 billion in market value. By the next Wednesday, with Altman returning, Microsoft was up 0.4% from before the news. The Nasdaq 100 was up 1.1%.

Microsoft lost about $47 billion of market value in one day over another company’s boardroom crisis. If a few big tech names carry most of your savings, one board fight can shake them. The Trefis Income Solution holds 50 dividend stocks yielding about 3x the S&P 500. Each has paid dividends for at least 10 straight years. See the Income Solution.

The table shows how small the dent was.

Stock Nov 17 Week after Year after
Microsoft −1.7% +0.4% +11.1%
Amazon +1.6% +2.7% +41.2%
Alphabet −1.2% +1.1% +28.3%
Nasdaq 100 (QQQ) 0.0% +1.1% +30.4%

Source: Trefis price data, dividend-adjusted closes. Changes run from the Nov 16, 2023 close to Nov 17 (the day of the news), to Nov 22, 2023, and to Nov 18, 2024.

Amazon and Alphabet are Anthropic’s big backers. A year is long, and AI, cloud and interest rates moved all of these stocks. So read the last column as context, not cause.

Did The Crisis Help Anthropic?

The data can’t say.

Anthropic’s own filing shows its rise, year by year. In 2023, its first year selling Claude, its sales were $41 million. In 2024 they were $386 million. They reached $4.6 billion in 2025 and $33.2 billion in the first nine months of 2026. Customers paying $100,000 or more a year went from about 20 at the end of 2023 to about 200 a year later.

That jump came after the crisis. But the filing credits the Claude 3 models of 2024. It also shows no quarter before 2025, so the weeks after November 2023 can’t be tested. Our modest claim: the crisis may have nudged some buyers. The models had to be good enough to win them.

Why did Anthropic grow? Businesses bought Claude. Why did they want a second AI lab? Big buyers want two suppliers for anything critical. That is an old buying habit. Anthropic’s filing says so itself, as a risk to its own business. Customers may prefer “multi-vendor AI strategies” to limit dependence on any single provider.

In our view, the decision that mattered came in 2021. That is when the founders left to build a second lab, before anyone asked for one. The same habit also limits Anthropic, because buyers keep a second supplier for it too. We look at why Anthropic won in Anthropic: $41 Million To $33 Billion. Why?

What Is A Leader’s Exit Worth?

It depends on how much of the stock rides on that leader.

Microsoft held OpenAI as one bet among many, and the shock cost it a day. Nvidia had no such cushion. Its board announced an investigation into reports that Jensen Huang was the target of a foreign intelligence effort. From the Nov 6 close, before that announcement, to Thursday’s close, Nvidia fell 21.8%. The S&P 500 fund slipped 2.6% over the same span. That span also includes Nvidia’s earnings report this week, on Nov 17.

Nvidia’s fall comes to about $980 billion of market value, in under two weeks. The record also suggests a leader’s first year can mislead, and the business decides the decade. We look at that record in Jensen Huang, Elon Musk Or Dario Amodei: Who Is The Better Leader For Investors?

Anthropic carries its own version of this risk, by design. It is a public benefit corporation, a company with a stated public mission as well as profit. A financially disinterested trust, one with no money at stake, can generally elect and remove a majority of its board. The filing calls its seven co-founders stewards of the mission. That is a choice made in the open, not a flaw. But a board decision can move this stock, as one moved OpenAI in 2023.

So here is our view, without a prediction. Own the landlords: Amazon, Microsoft and Google rent computing to the AI labs. You already hold them in an S&P 500 fund. Keep any single lab small enough that a leader shock like Nvidia’s is just a line on your statement. Spread your bet across the labs through those landlords, not across headlines.

The line to remember: a leader’s exit at OpenAI cost Microsoft one day. Nvidia lost about $980 billion in the two weeks around news about its own leader. In our view, the difference was how much of each stock rode on one leader.

Our own answer is a simple strategy. We own many quality companies in equal amounts, so no single leader decides how we do.

Found A Better Strategy? We’d Love To Learn.

Ours is the Trefis High Quality (HQ) Portfolio: 30 quality stocks in equal weight. Since its September 2020 launch it has returned more than 105%. If yours has done better, tell us about it. If not, come take a look.

See The HQ Portfolio

For education, not a recommendation to buy or sell.

For questions about this article or underlying research, email help@trefis.com.