AGG Lost Money Over 5 Years. Is 60/40 Broken?
Today’s big story: Could Anthropic Stock Fall 25%?
A 60/40 mix puts 60% of the money in stocks and 40% in bonds. The bonds are meant to be the safe half. Over the past five years, that half lost money.
The iShares Core U.S. Aggregate Bond ETF (AGG) is the standard yardstick for high-quality U.S. bonds. In the five years to the Nov 18 close, it returned −1.2%, with interest reinvested. Vanguard’s BND also returned −1.2%. Treasury bills (T-bills), short-term loans to the U.S. government, did better. Held through the SHV fund, they returned +19.7%.
So plain cash beat the “safe” half. The mix still did fine, because stocks carried it. The iShares 60/40 fund (AOR) returned +31.1%. That turned $1 million into about $1.31 million. The S&P 500 fund SPY returned +66.2%.
Almost all of the bond loss came in one year. In 2022, AGG fell 13.0%. That was its worst calendar year in our data, which goes back to 2004. SPY fell 18.2% that year, and AOR fell 15.6%. Bonds did not cushion the fall.
In 2008 they did. That year AGG rose 8.3% while SPY fell 36.8%. The difference matters, because the bond half is what pays the bills in a bad year.
In 2022, the half meant to pay the bills fell along with stocks. If you are close to retiring, how you build that half is a big decision. Bring your hardest question to a free 30-minute call with our partner advisory firm, by phone or video. No obligation. Book a free call.

How Did Each Mix Do?
The table adds two more mixes. AOA holds 80% stocks and 20% bonds. AOM holds 40% stocks and 60% bonds.
| Fund | 5 years | 2022 | 10 years |
|---|---|---|---|
| SPY stocks | +66.2% | −18.2% | +291.3% |
| AOA 80/20 | +42.5% | −16.2% | +158.0% |
| AOR 60/40 | +31.1% | −15.6% | +115.3% |
| AOM 40/60 | +20.8% | −14.5% | +78.0% |
| AGG bonds | −1.2% | −13.0% | +17.5% |
| SHV T-bills | +19.7% | +0.9% | +26.5% |
Source: Trefis, prices through Nov 18. Total returns, with all payouts reinvested.
The longer the bond, the deeper the five-year loss. A fund of 7- to 10-year Treasuries (IEF) lost 7.5%. Long-term Treasuries (TLT) lost 34.4%.
Was 60/40 Broken?
Not over ten years. In that time, AOR turned $1 million into about $2.15 million. AGG turned it into $1.17 million. In its worst drop of the past five years, AOR fell 21.6% from its peak. SPY fell 24.5%.
What broke was the bond half’s job in one kind of year.
What Is The Bond Half For?
It has two jobs. The first is paying the bills in a bad year. Then you do not have to sell stocks when they are low. We worked through that in Can A $2 Million Portfolio Pay You $4,000 A Month? The second job is to supply money to buy stocks after they fall.
Bonds do these jobs well in a recession. Interest rates tend to drop then, and bond prices rise when rates drop. Bonds do them badly when the threat is inflation and rising rates. In 2022, bonds fell with stocks, while T-bills held steady.
Last week brought a hot inflation report and talk of a Fed rate hike in December. That is the second kind of threat, on a smaller scale.
We looked at the 37 Fed rate hikes from 2004 to 2023. A year after a hike, long-term Treasuries (TLT) were up by a median 1.3%. The median is the middle result. TLT was higher a year later after 20 of the 37 hikes. The S&P 500 was up by a median 14.2%, and it was higher after 34.
One thing is better now. Bonds pay more income today than they did before 2022.
So What Should The Safe Half Hold?
In our view, 60/40 was not broken. Its bond half had its worst year in our data, and stocks still carried the mix over five years.
The useful split may be inside the safe half. T-bills can cover the next few years of spending. Bonds can cover a recession, when rates tend to fall. Years of rising rates would change our view. Then T-bills, not bonds, would be the better cushion.
Questions To Keep
- How many years of spending does your safe half hold in T-bills, not bonds?
- Was your mix built for a 2008 or for a 2022?
- Does a third cushion, such as gold, belong beside both? See How Much Gold Should A $1 Million Portfolio Own?
Which Bad Year Is Your Mix Ready For?
A 60/40 mix is a bet on which bad year comes next. In 2008, bonds rose while stocks fell. In 2022, the “safe” half fell 13% along with stocks. In our view, it pays to build for both.
Bonds are not the only source of income. A portfolio that pays more and falls less in a selloff can help in either kind of year.
More Income. Smaller Drops.
Is your portfolio paying you enough? The Trefis Income Solution holds 50 dividend stocks yielding about 3x the S&P 500, each with at least 10 straight years of dividends. It lost less than the S&P 500 in all 9 big selloffs since 2018. Why not choose a better approach?
For education, not a recommendation to buy or sell.
For questions about this article or underlying research, email help@trefis.com.