Alcoa (NYSE:AA) is a leading producer of alumina, aluminum and products made from aluminum. There was a time when the company’s results were closely eyed as it used to be the first Dow company to post earnings and gave investors a clue to the likely results of other industrial goods producers. However, Alcoa was recently ousted from the Dow Jones Index. Nevertheless, aluminum, being one of the most important industrial metals, is closely tracked and followed by analysts and investors alike. Although Russian company UC Rusal is the biggest producer of aluminum by volume, Alcoa’s foreign listing makes it more important from an investor’s point of view.
Alcoa is a fully integrated producer of aluminum: it mines bauxite, refines it into alumina, makes primary aluminum and also produces midstream products like flat rolled sheets and downstream engineered products.
In this article, we take a closer look at Alcoa’s alumina business division. We will describe the cost structure of the business, the pricing mechanism for alumina, the reasons behind the poor performance of the division in recent times, and the future outlook. You can also see our most recent earnings note here: Weak Prices Dent Alcoa’s Results But Value-Add Products Brighten Outlook
- Arconic’s Q4 2016 Earnings Review: Productivity Improvement Initiatives Boost Earnings Amid Top Line Headwinds
- Arconic’s Q4 2016 Earnings Preview: Near-Term Headwinds In Key End Markets To Weigh On Results
- Alcoa’s Q4 2016 Earnings Review: Higher Commodity Prices And Productivity Improvement Initiatives Boost Results
- Alcoa’s Q4 2016 Earnings Preview: Higher Aluminum Prices And Lower Cost Operations To Boost Results
- Alcoa’s Q3 2016 Earnings Review: Productivity Improvement Initiatives Drive Improvement In Results
- Alcoa’s Q3 2016 Earnings Preview: Productivity Improvement Initiatives To Boost Results
What Does The Alumina Division Do?
Alcoa’s alumina business involves processing bauxite and refining it to obtain alumina. It comprises Alcoa’s worldwide refinery system and bauxite mining operations. A major portion of bauxite mined by Alcoa is used internally. However, Alcoa also sources bauxite from third-party sellers to meet its requirements.
The alumina obtained by refining is sold directly to internal and external aluminum smelter customers worldwide or is sold to customers who process it into industrial chemical products. A portion of this segment’s third-party sales are completed through the use of agents, alumina traders and distributors. Slightly more than half of Alcoa’s alumina production is sold under supply contracts to third parties worldwide while the remainder is used internally by the primary metals segment to produce aluminum. 
In 2012, Alcoa’s alumina division revenues were $3 billion from third-party sales while inter-segment sales accounted for $2.3 billion worth of sales. In the first six months of 2013, third-party sales were $1.65 billion while inter-segment sales accounted for $1.2 billion worth of sales. 
Bauxite and caustic soda constitute nearly 50% of the production cost for alumina with bauxite’s share at approximately 30%. However, the precise breakdown shows large variations depending on the grade of bauxite used and proximity of the alumina refinery from the bauxite mine. Low grade bauxite needs more caustic soda for processing while transportation costs add to the overall cost of bauxite. 
The other cost components are electricity, natural gas, and fuel oil. Electricity costs are typically around 25% of total production costs for alumina.
Alumina has historically been priced as a percentage of the more liquid and transparent aluminum price quoted on the London Metal Exchange (LME). Contract terms have historically fluctuated in the range of 12-14% of the LME aluminum metal price. This ratio is typically arrived at through negotiations between alumina refiners and aluminum smelters, who are the customers. Spot prices have been much more volatile as the alumina spot market is a very thin market. For 2012, our calculations show that taking into consideration only third-party alumina sales, Alcoa’s average realized price for alumina was approximately 13.5% of the average realized price for aluminum.
Over the years, the aluminum industry has moved away from a vertically integrated model where producers had their own bauxite mines and alumina refineries. Many independent aluminum smelters have come up and they buy alumina in the spot market. In such a case, a fair price discovery can be better achieved through market mechanisms. 
Therefore, Alcoa has implemented a move to price alumina based on an index of spot alumina prices rather than as a percentage of LME-based aluminum price. This change is expected to affect approximately 20% of annual contracts coming up for renewal each year. It will more fairly reflect the fundamentals of the alumina business in its own right, including the cost of raw materials and transportation.
Over time, we expect the pricing to be driven by the demand-supply dynamics for alumina in its own right rather than being linked to aluminum. For Q3 2013, Alcoa expects around 53% of alumina third-party shipments to be linked to the alumina price index or spot price. When Alcoa releases its Q3 report next month, we will check whether this assertion has borne out.
While several indices are used by industry players, Alcoa favors the use of the index developed by Platts. 
Financial Performance Of The Alumina Division And Outlook
In Q2 2013, the alumina division reported after-tax operating income (ATOI) of $64 million compared to the Q1 2013 figure of $58 million. The ATOI for the primary metals segment, however, stood at a negative $32 million compared to a positive $39 million in the previous quarter. The performance of the primary metals segment was impacted by lower LME prices of aluminum but the improved performance of the alumina segment demonstrates that the two divisions are less inter-linked now than in the previous years. Indeed, the price index for alumina showed a positive trend in the quarter which helped offset the negative impact of alumina sales benchmarked against aluminum prices. 
The price of caustic soda, an input for alumina production, is expected to come down in the foreseeable future and productivity related improvements will continue. Aluminum has been trading at much lower prices than last year and the outlook for commodities isn’t looking up in the short term. QE tapering, if it happens, will lead to a stronger dollar and weaken commodity prices further.
At this time, the macroeconomic sentiment for Europe is weak and a dramatic turnaround in the U.S. is not likely. China is self-sufficient in aluminum and in fact has excess production capacity. In short, we don’t see much macroeconomic driven upside for aluminum prices going forward. This will keep margins and net profits down for the alumina division since at least half the quantity of alumina sold is still linked to aluminum prices. 
We have a Trefis price estimate for Alcoa of $7 after the second quarter earnings results.Notes: