This site requires a more recent version of Adobe Flash Player to function properly.
Go here to get Flash.
Trefis's graphical modelling tools require Flash, but here's a preview of some of the content you'll see once
Flash is enabled:
Investment Overview for Starbucks (NASDAQ:SBUX)
Starbucks' comps remain a drag, while revenue climbs higher
The latest quarter saw comparable store sales in the Americas rebounding to 5% y-o-y. However, a conspicuous downtrend is visible in the consolidated comps on a sequential basis. This downtrend is quite worrisome as is evident from the fall in the company's stock price. Compounding the situation is the lukewarm guidance (ranging in mid-single digits) provided by the company for comps for FY 2017, due to the weakness in many countries in Asia and Europe and the general macroeconomic uncertainty.
Despite the slowdown in comps, revenue grew 16% y-o-y. This is likely a result of the success of the company's beverage line-up, the success of roasteries, and the sustained growth in the channel development segment.
Continued focus on expansion in Asian markets
Although comparable sales for China and Asia Pacific (CAP) were up only slightly due to the weakness in Japan, for China they grew 6% year over year in the quarter. The revenues in the CAP region were up as much as 29% year over year, despite the moderation in China's GDP growth. The region continues to see numerous store openings, in line with Starbucks' plan to have 5,000 stores in China by 2021. Furthermore, the opening of the first reserve roastery in Shanghai indicates the confidence and the growth potential the company sees in the country.
Recently, the company mentioned its plans to bring its specialty tea brand, Teavana, to India in 2016. India is a major consumer of tea and Starbucks has been a huge success in the country. The introduction of Teavana, with the brand name of Starbucks backing it up, might just be a game-changing move from the company. With close to 80 stores, the growth of the company in India is faster than any other region, as stated by the company's officials.
Starbucks bets on Reserve Roastery and Tasting rooms to promote growth
Starbucks Reserve Roasteries are a way to showcase the newest coffee brewing methods and offer customers the finest assortment of exclusive micro-lot coffees from around the world, while continuing to innovate and experiment with new products such as nitro coffee, Affagato, and Teavana iced teas. The menu items in these Reserve stores are much more expensive than those in regular Starbucks stores.
The company has introduced Reserve coffees in over 1,200 regular stores worldwide, to drive additional customer traffic. Starbucks now serves Starbucks Reserve coffees in around 136 locations across 10 markets in China and the Asia-Pacific (CAP) region. It is planning to expand the availability of Starbucks Reserve coffees to over 1,000 locations. The roastery provides the company the opportunity to launch 500 Starbucks Reserve stores around the world.
Further, the success of the Seattle Roastery, which saw a significant increase in comps at 24%, is an example of what the company hopes to achieve through these premium stores. Following the opening in Shangai, it expects to open a roastery in New York City and Tokyo in 2018, and another in Europe in 2019.
Below are key drivers of Starbucks' value that present opportunities for upside or downside to the current Trefis price estimate for Starbucks:
Company Owned Stores
Company Operated Stores EBITDA Margin :The margins improved to 18.7% in 2010 from 16.5% in 2009 due to restructuring and store closures. However, in 2011, the margins dropped to 17.5%, primarily due to high coffee prices. In 2012, they remained relatively stable. In 2013, the margins increased to 20.6% as a result of low arabica coffee prices, and further to 22.3% in 2014. In 2015, however, coffee prices shot up resulting in margins again coming down to 21.9%. Experts believe that the coffee prices might shoot up again in 2016, due to weather setbacks to coffee crops in many major producing countries, including Brazil and Vietnam, besides a reluctance by Brazilian arabica growers to sell their bumper harvest, with stocks depleted by disappointing results to the two previous harvests. As a result, Starbucks margins may be pressured downwards to 17.0%, leading to an over 18% downside to the Trefis stock price. However, if the arabica coffee price rally halts and tests new lows, margins may improve to 26.0%, leading to an upside of 10% to the Trefis valuation.
Starbucks is the world’s leading roaster and retailer of specialty coffee. Through its global network of owned and franchised coffee retail outlets, Starbucks offers a wide range of products like high-quality whole bean coffees, freshly brewed coffees, Italian-style espresso beverages, cold blended beverages, food items like sandwiches, premium teas, and coffee making equipment.
Starbucks' own stores are located near offices and residential areas and are larger in size, compared to its licensed stores that are much smaller and mostly located at airports and supermarkets.
Starbucks also sells its packaged coffee and tea through retail channels such as grocery stores, warehouse clubs, convenience stores, and US food service accounts.
The Company Operated Stores division is more valuable than the Franchise Stores division for Starbucks because of the following two reasons:
Company operated stores generate more revenues than franchised stores
Starbucks makes money through its company-owned stores as well as through franchise fees and royalties from franchised stores. Starbucks earns higher profit margins from franchised stores compared to company-owned stores because there are no operational and employee costs involved with franchised stores, hence Starbucks gets to keep the entire royalty & rent fee without paying for any costs.
Revenues earned from Starbucks' company owned stores are much higher than the franchised stores. This is because, although there are costs involved, Starbucks owns 100% of the revenues from its own restaurants, while it gets a percentage of the revenues (in the form of royalty fees) from its franchised restaurants.
Number of company owned stores comparable to franchised stores
Food & beverage companies, in general, increase their reach and profits by having a large base of franchised stores. For example, McDonald's has four times more franchised restaurants than company owned restaurants, making the franchise business more valuable to its stock. However, Starbucks has almost an equal number of company owned stores and franchised stores. As of June 28, 2015, Starbucks had 12,095 company-owned stores and 10,424 franchised stores making a total of 22,519 stores.
International expansion fueling growth
Most of the new restaurants the company plans to open are in China/Asia Pacific. The number of Starbucks outlets in these countries are only a fraction of what they are in the U.S. New outlets opened will be a mix of company-operated and franchised restaurants. The company plans to take the store count in China to 3,400 by 2019. Shanghai alone has 320 Starbucks stores. Starbucks plans to double the store count in China & Asia-Pacific to 10,000 by 2019. Moreover, the company decided to take full ownership of Starbucks Coffee Japan Ltd. (Starbucks Japan). On September 23, 2014, Starbucks announced its intent to acquire the remaining 60.5% of Starbucks Japan through a two-step tender offer process for about $914 million. Similarly, it plans to double the number of restaurants in South Korea to 700 by 2016. The company plans to accelerate the expansion in India in the coming years.
Ease and convenience of payment through mobile apps helping domestic sales
As of June 28, 2015, Starbucks' mobile payments accounted for 20% of the net transactions in the U.S., with nearly 9 million transactions each week. Consumers can load the money on to the app and then present a 2D bar code to pay at the register. With this app, it’s easy to pay with a phone, track purchases, and view one's My Starbucks Rewards Stars and rewards.
Starbucks Reserve coffee initiative boosts revenue growth
In December 2014, Starbucks introduced a new concept and opened the first ‘Starbucks Reserve Roastery and Tasting Rooms’ in Seattle. Moreover, the company has introduced Reserve coffees in over 1,200 regular stores worldwide, to drive additional customer traffic. Starbucks now serves Starbucks Reserve coffees in around 136 locations across 10 markets in China and the Asia-Pacific (CAP) region. Reserve coffees are more expensive than regular coffee items, and the company is trying to expand the initiative throughout the U.S. stores.
Trefis Forecast Rationale for Average Number of Franchised Stores
This is the average number of coffee stores operating under the licensing arrangement between Starbucks and its various partners across the globe.
In 2011, the average number of franchised stores increased by 1.9% to 8,121. In 2012, the growth accelerated as the figure rose 4.5% to 8,509. The trend continued into 2013 as the figure surged 10.5% to 9,401 stores. The expansion growth continued its momentum in 2014, as the figure rose 6.2% to 9,984. In 2015, the metric again grew by 6.3% to 10,615.
The positive growth of franchised stores internationally has been negatively offset by store closures in the U.S. as part of the company's restructuring efforts to reduce self-cannibalization.
With restructuring now complete, we forecast more aggressive store openings. For 2016, the company targets to open nearly 750-800 stores, with primary focus in Asian markets. Beyond that, we expect the increase in the average number of franchised restaurants to be around 700-750 stores annually.
Trefis considered the following factors for its forecast:
- Rate of growth for franchised restaurants greater than company-operated restaurants
- Franchised restaurants require low investment and offer high margins (as high as 75%). Most of the new restaurants that the company is opening are franchised restaurants.
- International markets are under-penetrated
- Most of the new restaurants the company plans to open are in China/Asia Pacific. The number of Starbucks outlets in these countries are only a fraction of what they are in the U.S. New outlets opened will be a mix of company operated and franchised restaurants.
- The company plans to take the store count in China to 3,400 by 2019. Shanghai alone has 320 Starbucks stores.
- Similarly, it plans to double the number of restaurants in South Korea to 700 by 2016. The company also plans to accelerate the expansion in India in the coming years.
- Starbucks plans to double the store count in China & Asia-Pacific to 10,000 by 2019.
Back to Company Overview
- Lack of transparency in developing markets creates difficulty to franchise the restaurants
- It is often more difficult to franchise the restaurants in developing markets due to the lack of big franchisees which can match the stature of Starbucks. Similarly, there are quality issues with franchisees which could permanently damage the company's reputation in that particular region. In such a scenario, Starbucks is better off opening company operated restaurants.
How Does Trefis Modelling Work?
How do we get the historical numbers for this chart?
Trefis has a team of in-house Analysts who gather historical data from company filings and other verifiable sources. When historicals are available, we explain how we got them at the bottom of the Trefis analysis section below.
Who came up with the Trefis forecast for future years?
The Trefis team of in-house Analysts considers a variety of factors when projecting any forecast. The rationale for our projections is explained in the Trefis analysis section below.
How does my dragging the trendline on the chart impact the stock price?
- We use forecasts for business drivers to calculate forecasted Revenues and Profits for each division of the company.
- We then use forecasted Profits in a Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) model to obtain the Price Estimate for the company.
See more on: DCF Methodology
View All Help Topics