US same-store sales were down 1.3% YOY marking the sixth sequential quarterly decline. However, site traffic on Thanksgiving was up 50% YOY and 30% up YOY on Black Friday.We’ve previously examined the benefit from international expansion, but there is further potential upside to stock from US operations.
We currently have a Trefis price estimate of $65.42 for Wal-Mart’s stock, which is currently 20% above current price. Wal-Mart’s domestic operations and international operations currently constitute little less than two-thirds and around one-third respectively of our estimated intrinsic value for WMT.
- How Walmart Is Revamping Sam’s Club To Take On Competition?
- Why Is Walmart Making Gas Stations A Bigger Part Of Its Business?
- Walmart Kills Walmart Express: Are Neighborhood Market Stores More Productive?
- Is Walmart Increasing Its Focus On Indian E-commerce Market?
- Can Walmart-Pay Help Drive Revenues?
- Wal-Mart Exceeds Expectations In Q3 As Solid Store Performance Drives Top Line
With increased spending, we calculate a 2% stock price sensitivity to a 5% change in our forecasted total of 2013 international stores.
Although increased early holiday shopping could be indicative of a pick up in consumer spending, we note that improvements might also be due to a temporary release of pent-up demand. Still, there are other indicators suggesting improved consumer confidence amongst retailers. We wrote last week about the Cyber Monday sales lifting Best Buys Outlook, which also holds true for Wal-Mart. (See Best Buy’s Gross Margin Impact on Holiday Promotions.) Also, U.S container imports of toys increased by 20% on a YOY basis, according to trade intelligence firm PIERS.
Though we project the revenue per square foot for Wal-Mart US to remain flat, an 8% increase by end of our forecast period implies almost 6% upside to our current Trefis price estimate of $65.42.
Despite the trending declines in US same-store sales, Wal-Mart has maintained consistency in US gross profit margins over the past few years, ranging between 26 to under 28%, implying successful cost controls.
We project US gross profit margin to remain flat, however, should spending improve, an 2% increase by end of our forecast period would provide further upside of 4% beyond our current Trefis price estimate of $65.42. Wal-Mart’s price is highly sensitive to US gross profit margin, and an increase of US gross profit margin by 100 basis point adds nearly 3% upside.
Should these two scenarios materialize, there would be around 10% upside to our current Trefis price estimate of $65.42 (which is already 20% above market value). Excluding potential upside from international expansion, as previously discussed, this scenario could justify a $ 70 stock price Wal-Mart.
See our complete analysis for Wal-Mart here.