Evergreen Solar Illustrates Risks of Debt & Falling Solar Prices
Evergreen Solar (NASDAQ:ESLR) filed for bankruptcy earlier this week. The sad story of Evergreen’s demise illustrates the risks debt-laden solar companies face in an environment of falling solar prices due to tepid demand and industry overcapacity. While we currently do not cover Evergreen Solar, we cover similar companies in the solar sector including First Solar (NASDAQ:FSLR), SunPower (NASDAQ:SPWRA) and Suntech Power (NYSE:STP). Despite certain technical differences between the photovoltaic (PV) panels or modules offered by Evergreen Solar and those offered by other solar companies, there is a similar dependence on the sensitive (and falling) price of solar panels or modules across the industry. Using our analysis of Suntech Power, we highlight below the risks that Evergreen and other solar companies face.
A Dangerous Cocktail: Debt Mixed with Falling Solar Panel Pricing
The Debt
The initial state of the slideshow below shows how a large portion of Suntech Power’s firm value is diverted to debt holders. The equivalent of about $6 per share is owed to Suntech Power’s creditors. While we currently show a Trefis price estimate of nearly $11 for Suntech Power, the market is only awarding Suntech a value of about $6.50 per share.
[trefis_slideshow ticker=”STP” rhs=”3″]
Debt has the effect of magnifying the negative impact to shareholders of downturns in a company’s main business.
The Falling Photovoltaic Prices
In addition to a debt burden, Evergreen Solar suffered from falling PV prices caused by a mix of (i) reduced demand, in part attributable to subsidy reductions in Europe, and (ii) industry overcapacity, including growing capacity from Chinese manufacturers.
As Evergreen management highlighted on the March 2011 call for Q4 2010 earnings:
By the end of 2010, worldwide cell processing capacity reached approximately 30 gigawatts, a growth rate exceeding 50% over the prior year. Another 50% increase in capacity is forecasted by many in 2011, enabling the solar industry to support more than 45 gigawatts of cell capacity in 2012. [1]
Below we show how Suntech Power’s average selling price of PV modules has fallen from $3.90 per watt in 2008 to an estimated $1.60 per watt in 2011. Similar declines have been experienced by other players across the solar industry.
[trefis_forecast ticker=”STP” driver=”1246″]
By modifying the forecast shown above slightly downward, you can see just how sensitive Suntech Power’s stock is to PV pricing. This kind of sensitivity makes many of the solar stocks a risky bet on the downside. But, if you modify the forecast up slightly, you can see how the stock can appreciate by multiples of the current market price. At the end of the day, it’s greed vs. fear for solar investors.
See the full Trefis analysis for Suntech Power here.
Notes: