Paris Climate Agreement Spells Trouble For Coal

-10.40%
Downside
256
Market
230
Trefis
NSC: Norfolk Southern logo
NSC
Norfolk Southern

A global agreement reached at the recently concluded COP 21 climate change conference in Paris potentially spells trouble for companies associated with coal mining and transportation. Nearly 200 nations agreed on a plan that limits temperature rise as a result of global warming, to below 2 degrees Celsius or 3.6 degrees Fahrenheit from pre-industrial levels, in addition to “pursuing efforts” to limit warming to 1.5 degrees Celsius. [1] Though the Paris agreement allows countries to set their own emissions reductions targets, it is the first global accord that requires developing countries to lower their emissions growth, in addition to emissions reduction initiatives undertaken by developed countries. This implies that large carbon dioxide emitters, such as China and India, will have to chart out a lower emissions growth trajectory than currently factored into their plans for economic growth. These countries are among the top global consumers of coal as well, with China topping the list. A lower coal-intensive global growth trajectory will negatively impact companies with coal mining operations such as Cliffs Natural Resources, Vale, and Rio Tinto, in addition to railroad companies such as CSX, Union Pacific, and Norfolk Southern, which transport coal.

Weakening Coal Demand and Pricing

The market for thermal coal, which is used in electricity generation, is currently characterized by an oversupply situation. Coal producers have expanded production over the past few years, betting on Asian demand for the commodity to absorb the increased production. However, global demand for the commodity has not risen at the rates that coal miners envisioned. China, the world’s largest consumer of thermal coal, is systematically shifting away from thermal coal as a fuel for electricity generation, as a part of its crackdown on carbon dioxide emissions, which began before the landmark Paris climate agreement. In addition, the Chinese government has also placed restrictions on thermal coal imports in order to protect domestic coal production. As a result of weak domestic demand and import restrictions, Chinese imports of thermal coal fell 38% year-over-year in the first eight months of 2015. [2] With weak demand for the commodity, the worldwide surplus of seaborne thermal coal supply is expected to widen to 118 million tons in 2016, which is three times the surplus in 2013. [3]

Seaborne Thermal Coal Surplus, Source: Bloomberg

Relevant Articles
  1. What’s Next For Norfolk Southern Stock After A 21% Fall This Year?
  2. Which Is A Better Railroad Pick – Norfolk Southern Stock Or CSX?
  3. Will Norfolk Southern Stock Rebound To Its Pre-Inflation Shock Highs?
  4. Will Norfolk Southern Stock Trade Higher Post Q1?
  5. Why Did Norfolk Southern Stock Fall 30% Since 2021?
  6. Pick Either Norfolk Southern Stock Or This Travel Company: Both May Offer Similar Returns

Oversupplied coal markets have resulted in plummeting coal prices, which have driven the likes of Alpha Natural Resources, one of the largest coal producers in the U.S., into bankruptcy.

Impact of Paris Climate Agreement

With the signing of the Paris climate agreement, the demand for coal could decline at an accelerated rate, particularly since large emerging economies such as China and India will also now be limiting their respective growth in carbon dioxide emissions. To put the targets agreed on in Paris into perspective, emissions reduction pledges made by various countries prior to the conference would have resulted in global temperatures stabilizing at 2.7 degrees Celsius above pre-industrial levels. [4] The Paris deal has shifted the target to 2 degrees Celsius above pre-industrial levels. The following figure illustrates the projected carbon dioxide emissions in the various scenarios. As per these projections made by the PBL Netherlands Environmental Assessment Agency, the Paris agreement would require a 25% reduction in carbon dioxide emissions from the current trajectory of carbon dioxide emissions by 2030, and nearly 35% below emission levels in a scenario where no emissions reduction pledges have been made. 

Emissions Reduction Scenarios, Source: The Wall Street Journal

The conclusion of the Paris conference and the agreement on new global emissions reduction targets is likely to impact the business prospects of several companies that are associated with coal. Rio Tinto and Vale, which are diversified mining giants that also produce coal, have idled or sold off a significant proportion of their coal assets over the past couple of years. The developments at Paris are likely to be a further blow to the long-term prospects of these companies’ coal mining businesses. Cliffs Natural Resources, among the largest iron ore producer in the U.S., had already signaled its intention to sell off its coal mining division before the Paris conference. The Paris climate deal is likely to make it even harder for Cliffs to find buyers for its coal mining assets, especially its thermal coal assets. In addition, U.S. rail companies such as CSX, Union Pacific, and Norfolk Southern have reported steep declines in their coal shipments this year as cheap natural gas prices and unfavorable emissions reduction regulation have led to a decline in the proportion of coal-fired power plants in overall U.S. electricity production. The developments at the Paris conference will likely further dent the prospects of these companies’ coal shipment businesses.

The Paris climate agreement will be open for signature by member states from April 22, 2016 to April 21, 2017, post which it will have to be ratified by the respective member states. Countries will also communicate their nationally determined emissions reduction plans no later than submitting their instruments of ratification of the Paris agreement. [5] Thus, the impact of the Paris agreement could soon be felt on the usage of coal as a fuel. This would negatively impact a range of companies associated with coal, as previously mentioned in this article.

View Interactive Institutional Research (Powered by Trefis):
Global Large Cap | U.S. Mid & Small Cap | European Large & Mid Cap
More Trefis Research

Notes:
  1. Nations Unite in Global Agreement on Climate Change, Wall Street Journal []
  2. Coal is Problem for Glencore, Other Miners, Wall Street Journal []
  3. The World Has 118 Million Metric Tons of Coal It Doesn’t Need, Bloomberg []
  4. World Leaders in Paris Vow to Overcome Divisions on Climate Change, Wall Street Journal []
  5. Paris Agreement, Wall Street Journal []