Railroad companies such as Union Pacific (NYSE:UNP), CSX Corporation (NYSE:CSX) and Norfolk Southern (NYSE:NSC) have been charged with claims that they billed surcharges that were unrelated to fuel costs. It is charged that the companies colluded to inflate fuel surcharges, thereby collecting billions of free dollars. The litigation has recently been converted into class action status. 
The railroad industry was deregulated back in 1976. But, in 1995, the U.S. Department of Transportation founded the Surface Transportation Board (STB) to help resolve railroad rate and service disputes and to review railroad merger proposals. In 2005, railroad companies instituted a fuel surcharge program after which their profits started to soar. Over the past 5 years, their margins have continuously increased.
- Why Did CSX’s Metals Shipments Decline In Q1?
- How Have U.S. Rail Coal Shipments Been Impacted By Weak Natural Gas Prices?
- CSX’s Q1 2016 Earnings Review: Top Line Headwinds Negatively Impact Results
- CSX’s Q1 2016 Earnings Preview: Decline In Shipment Volumes And Fuel Surcharge Revenue To Negatively Impact Results
- How Did The Decline In Shipments And Oil Prices Impact CSX’s Operating Ratio In 2015?
- CSX: A Look Back At The Year 2015
The companies are alleged to have billed unreasonable surcharges between 2003 and 2008, not reflecting the actual fuel price hikes. In January 2011, the STB held hearings to determine whether it should review the exemptions, which is expected to continue in 2012. Revoking the exemptions would potentially impact railroad pricing flexibility, posing downside to the margins.
There are potentially two impacts.
First, if the allegations are proved to be true, the railroad companies will need to shell out penalties which will hamper their cash position as well as valuation. Second, if the exemptions over fixing railroad service rates are waived off, the companies will see their margins sliding south.Notes:
- UPDATE: Class-Action Status Granted in Fuel-Surcharge Case against Railroads, nasdaq.com, June 28, 2012 [↩]