Coach Needs A Bigger Moat

by Trefis Team
Rate   |   votes   |   Share

Successful companies need an economic moat. The term economic moat, coined by the fabled investor Warren Buffett, refers to the ability of a business to maintain competitive advantages in order to protect its long term profits and market share from competing firms. The term implies the presence of factors that allow a company to be able to match the product quality offered by its competitors, but at the same time outperform those competitors in profits. For firms in the luxury goods industry, this usually means a brand image that creates an aura of exclusivity. The flip side to the presence of such a brand image, however, usually means lower sales numbers per quarter. Therefore, each firm in the luxury goods market has to evaluate for itself the trade-off involved between activities that boost its sales and activities that protect its exclusive appeal to customers.

The Coach (NYSE:COH) brand is an affordable mid range designer handbag brand. It offers luxury products at price points where the European luxury players cannot compete effectively. At the same time, its handbags come with a quality and price tags that put them in the category of luxury for most consumers. Despite these factors, Coach has seen its market share fall from 19% to 17.5% between 2011 and 2012. Much of this share has been grabbed by competitors such as Michael Kors, Kate Spade and Tory Burch. Comparable store sales have also fallen for three consecutive quarters. Our analysis below evaluates why this might be so.

Read our complete analysis for Coach, Inc

Competition Imitates Competition

In a profitable industry, over time competition will erode any competitive advantages enjoyed by a firm. Once a firm establishes competitive advantages, its superior operations generate boosted profits for itself, thus providing a strong incentive for competing firms to duplicate the methods of the leading firm or find alternate better operating methods. Coach’s main competitor in the U.S. handbags and accessories market, Michael Kors, has done just that. Since going public in 2011, Michael Kors has operated in malls and street locations, sold accessories-heavy collections and priced its products in the “accessible” luxury spectrum – all three strategies that Coach had employed to propel itself into the market leader position in the market space over the previous decade. [1] Moreover, Kors’ marketing strategies have been more effective in managing to appeal to the consumer base. Coach, on the other hand, has not been able to effectively transition its strategies from targeting its aging demographic to the younger consumers.

Factory Channel Too Dominant

A data point of great interest regarding Coach is that it derives two-thirds of its North American sales from factory outlets. That figure represents nearly 50% of total sales, a percentage that is too high for a true luxury company. The most important difference between an outlet store and a retail store is that the former usually does not sell the newest products made by that brand. The products sold at outlet stores are generally left over items from the previous years’ stock. Usually, these products are sold at a heavy discount, and sometimes there are also sales that are offered on top of the discounts. Some outlet stores, like those that sell clothing and fashion accessories, may sell products that are of a slightly lower quality than those offered at a retail store. Taking these factors into account it is easy to draw some conclusions about Coach:

  • A significant percentage of Coach’s North American sales is being derived from lower priced sales at factory outlets. If this trend continues, we can expect profit margins for Coach to drop further.
  • The easy availability of Coach hand bags is no doubt affecting its brand image. If everyone can have a Coach hand bag, its appeal as a luxury product is suspect.
  • Given the easy availability of information on the Internet, and the pre-shopping opportunities of selection that it provides, it is possible that customers who want to buy Coach’s products are foregoing shopping in its retail stores and waiting for the same products to come up at its factory outlets, at lower prices. This might be the factor that is causing same store sales for Coach to go down. [2]
  • The frequency with which Coach offers discounts and coupon deals might be boosting sales numbers per quarter, but at the same time affecting the company’s brand image. A cursory glance at the Twitter pages of Coach [3] and its competitor Michael Kors [4] reveals that discounts are far more common for Coach’s products than its competitors in the accessible luxury goods space.

Ripple effect

According to the Luxury Goods Worldwide Market Study Fall 2013 by Bain & Company, the U.S. overtook China as the leader in consumer spending on luxury goods in the year 2013. However, one of the biggest factors driving consumer spending in this market was spending by the increasing number of Chinese toursits visiting U.S. cities such as Las Vegas and Los Angeles. Additionally, one might recall that one of the silver linings for Coach in its last quarter’s earnings was the 25% growth in sales in China. On the face of it, one might take these two points to mean that sales in the U.S. might recover on the back of Coach’s growing popularity with Chinese consumers. However, it is also possible that Coach’s eroding brand image as a leading luxury brand might turn the same customers away from the brand and this can impact the company’s sales numbers in China as well. [5]

Our $59.50 price estimate for Coach’s stock which stands at a ~25% upside to the market price.

  1. Michael Kors Takes on Coach, Bloomberg, March 2012 []
  2. Coach Outlet vs Retail []
  3. Coach Twitter []
  4. Michael Kors Twitter []
  5. Coach Q2 FY14 Earnings Call Transcript []
Rate   |   votes   |   Share


Name (Required)
Email (Required, but never displayed)
Coach Logo
  • commented 6 months ago
  • tags: COH
  • In fact, I recommend you call the beginning of spring models of men I was rejected,

    gucci online

    because you can not call me a recommendation,

    cheap gucci

    I would recommend, first I'm going to the counter to try,

    gucci shoes

    because I do not want to wear uncomfortable shoes recommended for everyone,

    gucci outlet

    so other users will curse me out.

    gucci bags outlet

    I would not hold up, it turned out,

    gucci sale

    I recommend these shoes are also comfortable and nice to wear on my feet so that you wear as well.

    gucci outlet online

    Let us talk about business shoes now,

    gucci handbags

    many boys wear suits and ties every day, very formal,

    gucci handbags

    but dress shoes felt uncomfortable footrest, has been very hard work every day,

    gucci purses outlet

    the soles are soft leather insole of the most comfortable fit.

    gucci factory outlet

    Let me say casual shoes, this is probably the highest rates of shoes,

    gucci bags

    and basically what occasion could see his shadow,

    gucci outlet online

    my suggestion is more textured leather material,

    gucci purses

    tendon soles more durable, and the best there is more than a pair of casual shoes,

    gucci handbags

    different styles colors easy to match.

    gucci shoes outlet

    Geox shoes known to be breathing, keep feet dry and comfortable.

    gucci shoes sale

    Finally, talk about sports shoes,

    gucci sneakers

    sports shoes breathable and more attention because of the movement of the foot most active sweat glands,

    gucci shoes online

    and a pair of sneakers and good ventilation can help you in a timely manner the heat,

    gucci shoes outlet

    sweat discharge, does not feel wet stuffy, has been a constant temperature in the foot environment.

    air jordans

    With the 2015 spring and summer men's Paris show last week staged,

    nike air jordans

    this men's week came to an end.

    jordan shoes

    Before the next spring and summer men's inventory trends,

    air jordans sale

    we take a look at as one of the men's one of the highlights of the design.

    authentic jordan shoes

    Although shoes compared to men's design limitations more,

    cheap air jordans

    but the designer is possible to display their creativity, so that more and more men's footwear "fancy."

    jordan shoes sale

    2015 spring and summer men's T-week stage,

    retro air jordans

    men's sandals, strap flat sandals and sneakers almost "third world",

    jordan shoes sale

    but all the details to make a creative and their characteristics.

    air jordans online

    Next, we took all the spring and summer 2015 men's list of the most eye-catching Week 10 pairs of shoes.

    nike outlet online

    Its 2015 spring and summer series with ballet as a muse.

    nike air max 90

    This inspiration is reflected not only in the design of clothing,

    nike air max shoes

    sandals and even model also resembles ballet shoes.

    air max 90

    2015 Spring Paris men's week,

    nike shoes outlet

    that both exaggerated pointed shoes like the Venetian gondola to wear in the feet,

    nike shox shoes

    Velvet uppers coupled with exquisite embroidery and Obscure,

    nike shox r4

    both warm red or elegant black, have revealed a thick Spanish style.

    nike shox nz

    If you think the fans just a woman's patent, it would be wrong.

    nike shox shoes

    VERSACE 2015 spring and summer men on the show,

    nike shox nz

    a full-pink styling overturned people pink definition.

    nike shox r4

    But this pair of pink shoes but did not significantly feminine,

    nike shox shoes

    with the right mix if it will be the highlight of the dress.

    nike shox shoes

    soles from 16 Polymer polymers, looks quite high-street style.

    nike shoes outlet

    After taking over MOSCHINO Jeremy Scott brought their own ideas of design.

    nike shoes online

    Lovely smile printed in bright yellow shoes who will designer "superficial, fun, popular"

    nike outlet store

    The design concept flourish, may in turn become the new season fashions.

    nike shoes sale

    This double kolor appear on the show is one of the sports sandals sandals masterpiece Fashion Week this season.

    cheap nike shoes

    So refreshing color, put it feels as if wearing the same summer.

    cheap coach handbags

    The Roman-style rather VERSACE strap sandals style is very retro.

    cheap gucci shoes

    Delicate purple ribbon weaving as decoration,

    cheap gucci shoes

    making nude-colored bandage does not seem too monotonous.

    cheap gucci purses

    This shoe resembles a boxing shoes high-top sneakers,

    cheap gucci sneaker

    the color is red, white and blue, with a strong French style,

    gucci outlet online

    and long-barreled strap design also makes it stand out in sports shoes.

    gucci bags on sale

    VERSACE Fashion Week this season is definitely the big winner in the footwear,

    gucci handbags outlet

    the show floor a variety of styles, but each pair are so delicate.

    gucci outlet store

    The striped oxford shoes colorful, vibrant but not too assertive,

    gucci shoes online

    with casual pants will be the finishing touch.

    cheap gucci sunglasses

    Men show floor this week despite the major brands have released the 2015 spring and summer,

    cheap gucci purses

    but it seems that many of the styles are somewhat "familiar."

    gucci factory outlet online

    Such as DOLOCE & GABBANA red and black loafers,

    gucci handbags outlet

    with exquisite embroidery and Obscure for salient points,

    gucci factory outlet online

    but this design has been able to see in other brands,

    gucci shoes outlet

    which began a few years to do men's ChristianLouboutin is one of the representatives.

    cheap gucci purses

    And in the style sandals, a big trend this season is menswear week straps,

    cheap gucci shoes

    just like VERSACE such delicate straps design is not much,

    gucci shoes sale

    most of the brand launched a simple and generous strap sandals or dominated.

    cheap gucci shoes

    Sneakers are the most abundant part,

    gucci shoes online

    designers have chosen to bring a bold unique beauty between fashion and sports style between the use of color and design.

    gucci shoes on sale

    Overall, this Fashion Week adequate design is actually the color of the shoes are rare,

    jordan shoes on sale

    perhaps because of men's design is still in an effort to break out of the state,

    retro air jordans

    but we still try new designers like to see brought,

    nike air jordans

    and believe which always has some nice shoes to attract the attention of consumers in the next year in spring and summer men's shoes set off a new season trend.

    jordan shoes on sale

    2015 spring and summer season to introduce you to the conference & exhibition refined analysis of children's shoes,

    jordan shoes

    Sports shoes sneakers still using bright colors and eye-catching styling,

    cheap jordan shoes

    bright metal, flash patch, Montreal prints and stripes decorated men's and women's shoes.

    air jordans sale

    Whether male or female shoes shoes,

    authentic air jordans

    Velcro (buckle) are the main details of street style and sneakers.

    air jordans

    Highlights the fashion bright neon colors.

    jordan shoes online

    Main season sneaker styling for the buckle strap lacing sneakers and high-top sneakers,

    nike outlet online

    suede leather, iridescent fabrics and cotton-padded tongue charge.

    cheap air max 90

    Women's shoes to help low season to remove a lot of decoration,

    cheap air max shoes

    and focus on printing, fabric, and rubber soles,

    cheap nike air max 90

    and a flash of bright metallic colors and multiple thick highly personalized.

    nike outlet online

    According to the trend of this season's men's shoes,

    nike shoes online

    the soles of Oxford to uneven shading decorated,

    nike shoes outlet

    with contrasting color details, conspicuous prints and cut openwork design.

    nike air max shoes

    Doll shoes women shoes, children's shoes in the wild,

    nike outlet store

    with dresses and casual wear can match to each other,

    nike factory outlet

    the spring and summer 2015 women's shoes this season's highlights for contrasting color toe.

    wholesale gucci online

    2015 spring and summer ballet flats shape,

    cheap gucci online

    metallic color printing from suede to ginning pattern, with different decorations.

    cheap gucci sale

    Candy-colored patent leather T-strap so simple sandals look, especially with the heavy decoration and 3D applique with time.

    discount gucci online

    This season, whether it is highly personalized Birkenstock sandals or thin strap sandals,

    discount gucci online

    cross-type multi-strap sandal strap and a girl's favorite.

    cheap gucci sale

    Conspicuous color trim, comfortable footbed, buckle strap and tactile soles designed for boys and girls sports sandals.

    discount gucci sale

    Polyethylene plastic as the main material of fisherman sandals,

    wholesale gucci online

    and gradually popular in the shoes market,

    wholesale gucci sale

    suede and leather material which is also the main.

    cheap gucci online

    Girls sneakers adds glitter decorative fabrics and thumbtacks.

    air jordan 1

    Buckle straps and rubber soles lightweight and comfortable.

    air jordan 13

    Get inspiration from all major brands of color combinations designed to spring and summer season of men's shoes continue to be bright colors,

    air jordan 11

    prints and textures designed to be personalized highlights.

    air jordan 5

    "Vacation noble" fresh and modern theme, inspired by the macro trends "Impulse" (ripple),

    air jordan 9

    mature style combines the feminine silhouette and street style sportswear aesthetic.

    jordan 1

    Vacation noble" fresh and modern theme, inspired by the macro trends "Impulse" (ripple),

    jordan 5

    mature style combines the feminine silhouette and street style sportswear aesthetic.

    jordna 7

    From white to black and white monotone summer,

    jordan 9

    bright colors and contrasting gray color with a very prominent,

    jordan 11

    conspicuous new mash contrast stripes and prints.

    nike air max 90 sale

    Sporty trim and functional fabrics, such as gauze,

    nike air max 90 online

    fiber crafts, simple silhouette, clothing adds a sports activity,

    air max 90 sale

    while highlighting the soft flowing fabrics feminine element.

    air max 90 online

    light pastel pink and orange color tones such as dynamic modeling for the summer to add vitality.

    nike free run shoes sale

    Holiday noble "theme of material used in motor function type mesh,

    cheap nike air max 2015

    Details and trim details and luxurious surface motion integration,

    nike zoom shoes sale

    interpretation of the harmonious styling.

    cheap nike air force 1

    Motion based play elements, such as neoprene, mesh and sports Wind soles.

    nike zoom kd online

    Meanwhile, flat, muffin bottom and stacked with the highlights.

    Cheap Gucci Online,Cheap Gucci Shoes,Cheap Gucci Belts Online

    sock style mash fresh interpretation of the shape of the upper.

    wholesale gucci bags

    thick retro sports shoes jogging shoes and learn the advantages of functional running shoes.

    Cheap Gucci,Cheap Gucci Shoes,Cheap Gucci Purses Online

    laminated mesh fresh interpretation of results,

    cheap gucci bags

    such as transparent PVC Ethylene upper concave footbed comfortable,

    Gucci Bags,Gucci Bags Outlet,Gucci Outlet Online

    stylish colors. asymmetrical upper sandals highlight modern styling.

    discount gucci bags

    shaping soles toe ring package fit the foot. thin strip surface treatment elegant,

    Gucci Online,Gucci Outlet Online,Gucci Sale Online

    stylish cover large transparent gauze and clean PVC Ethylene fresh interpretation of upper high heel boots showing dramatic new mixed results.

    discount gucci wallets

    satin uppers and slender styling inspired by the sport of boxing boots vinyl acetate copolymer soles,

    Cheap Gucci Handbags,Cheap Gucci Shoes,Cheap Gucci Sunglasses Online

    uppers round sculpted styling and fresh.

    wholesale gucci sunglasses

    Montreal mesh upper Unified Sports Elements and elegant silhouette interpretation of fashion mixing.

    Gucci Factory Outlet,Gucci Factory Outlet Online,Gucci Outlet Online

    hasp reflect movement elements. boyfriend style sneakers reflect neutral modeling.

    mens gucci shoes

    luxury leather and lined with neoprene socks effect highlighting luxury traditional silhouette,

    Cheap Gucci Bags,Cheap Gucci Purses,Cheap Gucci Handbags Online

    minimalist upper and pure Shoe colors for the highlights online - IT professional shoes shoes,

    womens gucci shoes

    shoe style design gallery, designed shoe designers,

    Gucci Shoes,Gucci Shoes Outlet,Cheap Gucci Shoes Online Sale

    design enthusiasts shoes, shoes, shoe design business owners to provide the latest information .

    gucci belts outlet

    2015 trends in shoes, spring and summer 2015 women's conference season presentation focused on color analysis.

    Gucci Shoes Online,Mens Womens Gucci Shoes,Gucci Shoes Sale For You

    Shoes lemon juice wine yellow pastel colors such as vibrant bright new spring and summer 2015 is the season of color,

    gucci sunglasses online

    such as bright sunshine yellow color Blocks of color combinations and contrasting color orange for the fire,

    Authentic Air Jordans,Jordan Shoes Online Sale

    Whether casual shoes or dance shoes,

    Air Jordans,Jordan Shoes,Cheap Air Jordan Shoes Online

    fire orange can be the perfect control.

    Nike Air Max,Nike Air Max Shoes,Nike Outlet Online Sale

    highly personalized red and orange hues complementary large,

    nike air max shoes sale

    the same season conference The main leisure sports flat shoes,

    nike air max 95

    solid color highlight the vitality and heel with harmony and luxury.

    Air Max 90,Nike Air Max 90 For Cheap Sale

    From fresh mint green to green, dark green or dark matter leaves,

    nike air max 87

    green in the conference this season are the main colors,

    discount nike air max

    so that the material exudes shimmer satin and leather and canvas to make casual style regained relaxed summer style from metal bright,

    Nike Shox Nz,Cheap Nike Shox Nz,Nike Shox Nz Sale Online

    shoes with classic denim color still primarily high bright leather more retro feel,

    Nike Shox R4,Nike Shox Shoes,Nike Shox R4 Online

    creamy texture of blue tones highlight the maturity profile shape.

    Cheap Nike Shox R4,Cheap Nike Shox R4,Nike Shox R4 Sale Online

    After reading the grass green theme, we also see blue-green appeared in the press conference.

    Nike Shox Sale Online,Discount Nike Shox Shoes

    From the bright turquoise blue color to the classic green,

    Nike Factory Outlet Online,Nike Factory Outlet Shoes Store

    blue and green the previous quarter,

    Gucci Belts,Gucci Belts Outlet,Gucci Belts Online

    retro blue adds vitality from sweet purple, strawberry, watermelon color to bright blue and green,

    gucci belts outlet

    pastel pink color macarons style appeared in the conference this season.

    designer belts online

    styling and flat boots for men, the female models heel and high-heeled.

    cheap louis vuitton belts

    soft neutral colors, such as light brown, gray, cream,

    cheap gucci belts

    are the main color in the spring and summer of 2015.

    Tiffany And Co Jewelry,Tiffany And Co Outlet Online Sale

    The same applies to clothing color cosmetics for the minimalist silhouette adds a refined sense of whiskey brown as the main color to return this season,

    tiffany and co jewelry online

    From the dark brown suede leather, fabric material is different.

    designer jewelry sale

    2015 spring and summer very commercially attractive monochrome color is still the main focus of color in spring and summer 2015 conference.

    tiffany and co jewelry sale

    White filled in a variety of shapes, whether casual flat or high-heeled personality.

    tiffany and co necklace sale

    Black and white also demonstrates the summer personality style,

    chanel jewelry online

    design or materials for decorative stitching.

    chanel necklace sale

    Shoe Design Online is a professional shoe design,

    juicy couture jewelry online

    designed to provide information for the shoe designer shoes,

    juicy couture necklace sale

    fashion shoes style trend analysis and browsing online map services.

    Oakley Outlet,Cheap Oakley Sunglasses,Oakley Sunglasses Online

    2015 shoe trends, with flat summer sandals have a long central loop belt,

    cheap oakley sunglasses

    slim leather belt loop also bifurcation side extension.

    cheap designer sunglasses

    With wooden beads to create natural decor.

    cheap prada sunglasses

    Multi-loop strap sandals with a two-tone leather,

    cheap ray.ban sunglasses

    using layered leather soles to build, simple fastener complements the soft colors.

    cheap louis vuitton sunglasses

    2015 shoe trends, through soft butter leather flat shoes were interpreted, large leather bow also decorated the design, color stitching between summer and dried flowers printing selection.